We have known for many years that we
need to improve our schools. The primary stumbling block is the vast
disagreement about what should be improved, what factor(s) quantify
the improvement, and what parties are primarily responsible for the
needed improvement.
A definite case for needed improvement
was made by A Nation At Risk , which warned in 1983 that our
students were not keeping up with their international peers. Since
that time, hundreds of reports and surveys have demonstrated that
large numbers of young people leave school knowing very little about
history, literature, foreign languages, the arts, geography, civics,
or science. The consequences of inadequate education have been
recently documented in books such as The Dumbest Generation, Just
How Stupid Are We? and The Age of American Unreason. The
authors of these books and many others describe in detail the
alarming gaps in Americans' knowledge and understanding of political
issues, scientific phenomena, historical events, literary allusions,
and almost everything else one needs to know to make sense of the
world. Without such knowledge and understanding, one tends to become
a passive spectator rather than an active participant in the great
decisions of our time.
Education is the
key to developing human capital. The nature of our education system
(mediocre or excellent) will influence our society far into the
future. It will affect our economy and our civic and cultural life.
Freedom can not be sustained if the citizens are uninformed and
indifferent about the history of our nation and past nations, the
different forms of government, and the workings of the economy. Our
nation will not be able to prosper if it neglects to educate its
children in the principles of science, technology, geography,
literature, and the arts.
Our great challenge
is to create a renaissance in education, one that goes well beyond the
basic skills that have become the singular focus of federal activity.
We need a renaissance that seeks to teach the best that has been
known and done in every field of endeavor.
The current
policies this nation is following have shown and continue to show
that improvement in the schools is not happening. Much of what
policymakers now demand is actually making our schools less effective
and continues to degrade the intellectual capacity of our citizenry.
The schools will surely be failures if students graduate knowing how
to choose the right option from four bubbles on a multiple choice
test, but at the same time are left unprepared to lead fulfilling
lives, to be responsible citizens, and to make good choices for
themselves, their families, and our society.
For the past
century or more, education reformers have tried out their ideas in
the schools. A wide variety of reformers and reform movements have
offered their own diagnoses and cures. With the best of intentions,
reformers have sought to correct deficiencies by introducing new
pedagogical techniques, new ways of organizing classrooms, new
technologies, new tests, new incentives, and new ways to govern
schools. In every instance, reformers believed that their solution
was the very one that would transform the schools, make learning fun,
raise test scores, and usher in an age of educational efficiency. As
one innovation follows another, as one reform overtakes the last,
teachers may be forgiven if from time to time they suffer from an
acute case of reform fatigue.
This constant
reform churn is not the approach found in countries having successful
schools. After years of studying successful schools from abroad, a
common list of essential ingredients were found:
a strong
curriculum; experienced teachers, effective instruction; willing
students; adequate resources; and a community that values education.
The fundamentals of
good education are to be found in the classroom, the home, the
community, and the culture. The reformers in our time continue to
look for shortcuts and quick answers. Untethered to any genuine
philosophy of education, our current reforms have disappointed us and
will continue to do so. The reform movement has been nothing but a
series of distractions, wrong turns, and lost opportunities. It is
time to reconsider not only the specific reforms, but also our very
definition of reform.
Our educational
problems are a function of our lack of educational vision, not a
management problem that requires an army of business consultants.
Certainly we should mobilize managerial talent that ensures school
facilities are well maintained, that teachers have adequate supplies,
that non-instructional services function correctly, and that schools
are using resources wisely.
A few of our
nation's reformers do suggest sound methods for improving schools,
such as improving curriculum and instruction and improving the
conditions in which students learn and teachers work, rather than
endlessly squabbling over how school systems should be organized,
managed, and controlled. I maintain that sound changes within
curriculum and instruction are meaningless unless the community and
the students truly value education, discipline, and rigorous study.
In my 30+ years of experience, I have come to the conclusion that
schools are only as successful as the community and culture in which
it serves. The organization of the schools is not at fault for the
ignorance that we deplore, but the lack of sound educational and
behavioral values is a definite factor in the propagation of under
performing schools.
Our schools will
not improve if elected officials intrude into pedagogical (how do we
teach) territory and make decisions that properly should be made by
professional educators. Congress and state legislatures should not
tell teachers how to teach, any more than they should tell surgeons
how to perform operations (although, this could be right around the
corner). Nor should the curriculum of the schools be the subject of
a political negotiation among people that are neither knowledgeable
about teaching or even well educated. Pedagogy should be the
professional domain of the individual teachers. Curriculum (what to
teach) should be determined by professional educators and scholars,
after due public deliberation, acting within the authority invested
in them by the schools, the districts, or states.
Our schools will
not improve if we value only what tests measure. The tests we have
now provide useful information about students' progress in reading
and mathematics, but they cannot measure what matters most in
education. Not everything that matters can be quantified. What is
tested may ultimately be less important than what is untested, such
as a student's ability to seek alternative explanations, to raise
questions, to pursue knowledge on their own, and to think
differently. If we do not treasure our individualists, we will lose
the spirit of innovation, inquiry, imagination, and dissent that has
contributed powerfully to the success of our society in many
different fields of endeavor.
Our schools will
not improve if we rely exclusively on tests as the means of deciding
the fate of students, teachers, principals, and schools. When
standardized tests are the primary means of evaluation and
accountability, everyone feels pressure to raise the scores, by hook
or crook. Some schools, as documented in several national cases,
will cheat to get a reward or to avoid humiliation. Schools may
manipulate who takes the test and who does not; district and state
officials may fiddle with the scoring of the test. Districts and
states may (and usually do) require intensive test preparation that
mirrors the actual state tests and borders on institutionalized
cheating. Any test score gains that result solely from incentives
are meaningless because gains that are purchased with cash are short
lived and have nothing to do with real education.
An unintended
consequence that evolves from the dependence on standardized test
scores for evaluating schools is that the lowest common denominator
becomes our focus for achieving success. The schools have come to
accept that the higher achievers will pass the minimum standards with
very little effort, therefore the total focus of all endeavors is
turned towards the underachievers. In essence, the curriculum of the
school becomes driven by the lowest achievers, leaving the students
with higher levels of competence and behavior to fend for themselves.
The dumbed down state tests create a dumbed down environment, focused entirely on
the lowest quartile of students.
Our schools will
not improve if we expect them to act like private, profit-seeking
enterprises. Schools are not a business, but a public good. The
goal of education should not be producing higher test scores in one
or two disciplines, but to educate children to become responsible
people with well-developed minds and good character. The unrelenting
focus on data that has become commonplace in recent years is
distorting the nature and quality of education. There are many
examples of healthy competition in schools, such as science fairs,
essay contests, debates, chess tournaments, and athletic events. But
the competition among schools to get higher scores is of a different
nature; in the current climate it is sure to cause teachers to spend
more time preparing students for state tests, not on thoughtful
writing, critical reading, scientific experiments, or historical
study.
The leader of each
individual school is the principal. Shouldn't the leader be a proven
master teacher and not some neophyte educator who may have taken a
few leadership training courses but have little or no successful
experience as teachers. The best principals should have a long
apprenticeship as educators, first as teachers, then as assistant
principals, and finally as principals. If principals have not spent
much time as successful teachers, they are not qualified to judge
others' teaching, nor can they assist new teachers.
Our schools cannot
be improved by blind worship of data. Data are only as good as the
measures used to create the numbers and as good as the underlying
activities. If the measures are shoddy, then the data will be
shoddy. If the data primarily reflects the amount of time invested
in test-preparation activities, then the data are worthless. If the
data are based on dumbed-down state tests, then the data are
meaningless. A meaningful accountability system (for teachers,
schools, and students), must include a variety of measures, not only
dubious test scores. Our schools should be data-informed versus
being data driven.
I disagree
vehemently with most contemporary public school officials on the
topic of school choice. The concern of the public schools is that
with CHOICE and VOUCHERS, the motivated students and families will be
siphoned away from the regular public schools. They fear that a continuation of
this path will debilitate public education in many of our nation's
school districts. Earlier in my career, I was in agreement with many
of my peers, but recent events have turned me 180 degrees from that
position.
Years ago, most
public schools took on the culture and academic expectations of the
community it served. In many suburban and rural districts, this
trend still exists. Families are increasingly finding that the
public schools (primarily in urban areas) are more committed to the
goals and agenda of the political ruling class. In essence,
public schools have become a primary propaganda tool of
the ruling class. Unless a school can provide a safe environment for our
children to learn and play and prepare them with a “sane/responsible”
and rigorous liberal arts education, families deserve to have their
children in schools that meet their standards and don't counter their
personal family values. While sympathetic to the challenges of today's public school system, I look at my grandaughter and respond, "I'm not going to let your problem become our problem." There are many great public schools in the Valley of the Sun. People who live in those districts are blessed, but those "not-blessed" have to worry about their own kids and the education that they will receive.
I guess what I am
saying is that until the public schools clean up their act (usually
not the fault of the particular school), parents have the right to
use their “tax expenditures” to place their kids in the schools
of their choice (including private schools). A local columnist with the Arizona Republic shares
my thoughts on the improvement of public schools, while facing the
challenge of educating our own kids:
“There’s a lot of heartbreak in
Arizona public education, mostly involving low-income kids not
learning enough to obtain a decent shot at upward mobility. But
there’s heartbreak when achieving kids are thwarted as well.
There’s not enough room in Gilbert’s rigorous Classical Academy
for all the students who want in. We keep trying to improve education
by doing big things. Perhaps we should focus on smaller things –
such as making sure any student who wants a rigorous curriculum can
get it.”
Our
schools can not be improved if we use them as society's all-purpose
punching bag, blaming them for the ills of the economy, the
dysfunction of families, and the erosion of civility. If there is
one thing all educators know, it is that there is no single answer for
educational improvement. I believe the columnist, Robert Robb, hit
the nail on the head in that we keep trying to improve education by
doing big things and wasting big amounts of money and energy in doing so. I see
a similarity of the national goal of public school improvement with our
nation's endless “war on poverty.” Tons of money and energy wasted and
not much to show for it.
In
closing, what is it that we want our kids to learn and accomplish by
the time they graduate from school. We want our kids to be able to
think for themselves when they are out in the world on their own. We
want them to have good character and to make sound decisions in their
life, their work, and their health. We want them to face life's joys
and travails with courage and humor. We hope they will be kind and
compassionate in their dealings with others. We want them to have a
sense of justice and fairness. We want our kids to understand our
nation, our world, and the challenges we face. We want them to be
active, responsible citizens, prepared to think issues through
carefully, to listen to differing views, and to reach decisions
rationally. We want them to learn science and mathematics so they
understand the problems of modern life and are able to participate in
finding solutions. We want them to enjoy the rich artistic and
cultural heritage of our society and other societies.
As we
continue to make the testing regime our master, we may see our true
goals recede farther and farther into the abyss.

By Walter Williams:
ReplyDeleteProfessor Craig Frisby is on the faculty of University of Missouri’s Department of Educational, School and Counseling Psychology. His most recent book is “Meeting the Psychoeducational Needs of Minority Students.” It’s a 662-page textbook covering a range of topics from multiculturalism and home and family influences to student testing and school discipline. There’s no way full justice can be given to this excellent work in the space of this column, so I’ll highlight a few valuable insights he makes that would help educators do a better job with minority students......
.....Frisby turns his attention to school discipline and criminal behavior. He discusses the atmosphere at one New York school, which is by no means unique among schools. Teachers experience being pushed, shoved and spit upon by students. A male teacher transferred to another school after a student threatened to rape his wife. In this kind of atmosphere, should anyone be surprised that only 3 percent of the students were at grade level in English and only 9 percent in math?
The fundamental problem crippling low-income minority students is school behavioral disorder. Its visible manifestations are graffiti, broken and vandalized furniture, fights, sexual activity, drug use in the bathrooms and rowdy behavior. Frisby says we should tell students exactly how to behave and tolerate no disorder. That’s not rocket science, except for today’s liberal establishment who run our schools and colleges.
You say, “Williams, what Frisby says simply reflects the insensitivity of privileged white people.” But what if I told you that Professor Craig Frisby is a black professor at the University of Missouri who has a record of fine scholarship? My read of his book is that it supplies more evidence that the actions of soft-minded, guilty white liberals have done far more harm to black people than racists of the past could have ever done.
http://www.humanevents.com/2013/04/04/the-needs-of-minority-students/