Culture

CULTURE.......

Language
: the oldest human institution and the most sophisticated medium of expression.

Arts & Sciences : the most advanced and refined forms of human expression.

Thought : the ways in which people perceive, interpret, and understand the world around them.

Spirituality : the value system transmitted through generations for the inner well-being of human beings, expressed through language and actions.

Social activities : the shared pursuits within a cultural community, demonstrated in a variety of festivities and life-celebrating events.

Interaction : the social aspects of human contact, including the give-and-take of socialization, negotiation, protocols, and conventions.

Monday, June 25, 2012

Words of Wisdom from F.A. Hayek and others...



From F.A. Hayek:  The Road To Serfdom; 1944 (Condensed and edited) 

The goal of central planning is described as taking care of the general welfare of the citizenry.  There has never been any real agreement as to the ends that are to be attained.  The effect is that a large number of people commit themselves to a journey without agreeing as to a specific final destination (I think of our War Against Poverty).  Ultimately, by the time the journey is advanced, most people have found that they have headed where they do not want to go.

About this time, a cry for a benevolent, economic dictator follows as a dictatorship is the most effective instrument of coercion, which is essential if central planning is to be effective.  Democracy and free elections, in itself, does not keep the source of power from dictatorial qualities (In our system, the growing Imperial Presidency will certainly lead to a dictatorship).


The totalitarian leader must collect around him a group which is prepared to submit to that discipline in which they are to impose by force on the rest of the people.  The Socialist Parties of old Europe were inhibited by their democratic ideals; they did not have the ruthlessness required for the performance of the chosen task.  The mistake of those parties that preceded Hitler and Mussolini was that they refused to take over the responsibilities of the type of government in which they were endorsing.  They still hoped for a majority that would agree on any particular plan which would benefit the WHOLE of society. (It has been said that a mixture of free market and socialism is worse than any of the two) Those coming after (the tyrants), had already learned the lesson that in a planned society the question can no longer be "on what do the majority of the people agree" but "what is the largest single group in whose members will sufficiently agree with the ruling class."


There are three primary reasons why a large group with similar views is not likely to be formed by the best that society has to offer, but rather by the worst elements of that society.  Who do the "dictators in waiting" go after to bring them into an absolute power?


  • The higher the education and intelligence of the individual becomes, the more their tastes and views are differentiated.  If we wish to find a high degree of uniformity in outlook, we have to descend to the regions of lower moral and intellectual standards.  This does not mean that the majority of people have a low moral standard, it merely means that the largest group of people whose values are similar are the people with the low standards (think of whom the present day Imperial Presidency panders to).  Very intelligent and educated people may be seduced by the dictatorial ruling class, but they do not make up the largest segment of the group in which they are a part of (the present day left wing intelligentsia and the Hollywood crowd).  
  • Since this group is not large enough to give sufficient weight to the leader's endeavors, he will have to increase their numbers by converting more to the same sort of fundamental beliefs.  He will have to gain the support of a docile and gullible, who have no strong convictions of their own but are ready to accept a ready-made system of values and imperfectly formed ideas if it is only drummed into their ears loudly and frequently (the head in the sand citizenry that does not want to take the time to fully understand the issues of the day; looking for a path of less resistance and outward approval, by not ever willling to take an unpopular stand - I call them the spineless). It will be those whose vague and imperfectly formed ideas are easily swayed and whose passions and emotions are easily aroused who will swell the ranks of the totalitarian party (a people whose life is guided more by emotion than by ideas and discipline).
  • To weld together a closely coherent body of supporters, the leader must appeal to a common weakness.  It seems to be easier for people to agree on a negative program (such as the hatred of a particular group or the envy of the better off) than on a positive task.  The contrast between "we" and "they" is consequently employed by those who seek the allegiance of huge masses.  The enemy may be internal, (such as those with strong religious beliefs or the rich).  At any rate, this technique has proven successful in the past and gives the leader greater freedom of action than any positive program.
Advancement within all totalitarian groups depends largely on a willingness to do immoral things.  The principal that the end justifies the means is the supreme rule in collectivist ethics.  There is nothing which the consistent collectivist must not be prepared to do if it serves "the good of the whole," ... (good is determined by the totalitarian regime).

Once one admits that the individual is merely a means to serve the ends of the state, most of those horrifying features of totalitarianism will follow out of necessity.  In the totalitarian machine there will be special opportunities for the ruthless and the unscrupulous.  Places of influence have no room for humanitarian feelings.

The most effective way of making people accept the validity of the values in which they are to serve is to persuade them that they are really the same as those they already held, but which were not properly understood or recognized before.  The most efficient technique is to use "old words" but change their meaning (freedom, human rights, equality, distorting the meaning and context of Biblical scriptures, etc.)


Traditional western values are held in very low esteem amongst the collectivists (past must be destroyed).  These virtues include independence, self-reliance, individual initiative, local responsibility, reliance on voluntary activity, non-interference with one's neighbor, and a healthy suspicion of power and authority.  These are the values that the collectivists are progressively destroying.


Our republic was based on the Rule of Law.  This means that government in all its actions is bound by rules fixed and announced beforehand - rules that make it possible to foresee with fair certainty how the authority will use its coercive powers in given circumstances.  This allows the individual to plan his affairs on the basis of this knowledge.  Within the rules of this game, the individual is free to pursue his personal ends, certain that the powers of government will not be used deliberately to frustrate his efforts.


Socialist economic planning involves the opposite of the Rule of Law.  The planning authority can not tie itself down in advance to general rules which prevent arbitrariness.  "The more the state plans, the more difficult planning becomes for the individual."


The difference between the Rule of Law and the Rule of Man is the same as that between providing signposts and commanding people which road to take.  In a planned society the law must legalize the arbitrary action of the planning authority.  Anything that the authority does is legal, thus its actions are not subject to any Rule of Law.  By giving government unlimited powers the most arbitrary rule can be made legal.


Immanuel Kant: "Man is free if he needs obey no person but solely the laws."


It is no stretch of the imagination to say that if we had to rely on central planning for the growth of our industrial system, it would never have reached the degree of differentiation and flexibility it has attained.  Modern civilization has been possible because it did not have to be consciously created.


Proponents of central planning will appease us that this authoritarian direction will only apply to economic matters.  They suggest that by giving up freedom in the less important aspects of our lives, we shall obtain freedom in the pursuit of higher values.  On this basis, people who abhor the idea of a political dictatorship are very vocal for a dictator in the economic realm.


Money IS one of the greatest instruments of freedom ever invented by man (money is the root of all evil, but money itself is not evil).  Money opens an astounding range of choice to the poor man - a range greater than that which not many generations ago was open only to the wealthy.  The so-called economic freedom which the planners promise us means precisely that we are to be relieved of the necessity of solving our own economic problems and that the bitter choices which this often involves are to be made for us.


Our freedom of choice in a competitive society rests on the fact that, if one person refuses to satisfy our wishes, we can turn to another.  But if we face a monopolist we are at his mercy.  An authoritarian directing the entire economic system would be the most powerful monopolist imaginable.


The will of the authority would shape and guide our daily lives, even more, in our position in the work place.  For most of us the time we spend at work is a large part of our whole life.  Our job usually determines where we live and amongst whom we live.  Few people ever have an abundance of choice of occupation.  But what matters is that we have some choice, that we are not absolutely tied to a job which has been chosen for us, and that if one position becomes intolerable, or our heart is set on another, there is usually a possibility to achieve this goal.  Nothing makes conditions more unbearable than the knowledge that no effort of ours can change them.


History shows us that any central planning government must control the trades and occupations, or the terms of renumeration, or both.  In almost all prior instances of central planning, the establishment of such controls and restrictions was among the first measures taken.


The problem with ignorant, short-sighted and lethargic people is they want to be relieved from the consequences of making choices or held accountable for the consequences of wrong choices.  In essence, people are not necessarily asking for others to make the choices for them, they just resent that choices are necessary.  What they resent is known as the economic problem (In short, the economic problem is the choice one must make, arising out of limited means and unlimited wants..)


What about planning for economic security?  There are two kinds of security: the certainty of a given minimum of sustenance for all and the security of a given standard of life.  With the wealth that has been found in the USA, having a first kind of security would appear to be "do-able" without giving away any form of general freedom.  I believe this type of security has been achieved in that minimum levels of food, shelter, and clothing have readily been available to the populace.  There is no reason why the state can not help organize a comprehensive system of social insurance to provide for those who get knocked back by the common hazards of life.


It is planning for the second kind of security which has a negative effect on liberty.  This is a planning designed to protect individuals or groups against any decrease of their incomes.  It has become increasingly true that members of each trade in which conditions improve are allowed to reap some of the increase in the form of higher wages and benefits.  Also, those in trades where demand has fallen off have nowhere to go, with the result being larger unemployment.  When the state offers grants of security to one group (unions, federal workers, favored businesses, etc) the insecurity of the rest always increases.  If you guarantee to some a fixed part of a variable cake, the share left to the rest is bound to fluctuate proportionally more than the size of the whole.  In other words, as the favored portion is mandated more security, the rest become less secure and more anxious.


"Ironic that our public university's propaganda machine has convinced so many that someone making a profit by employing 100 people is exploitation, but one bureaucrat commanding 100 people is honorable"

Monday, June 18, 2012

UNDERSTANDING OF THE UTOPIAN MODEL AND IT'S INFLUENCE ON OUR AMERICAN SOCIETY




INTRODUCTION



In Genesis 1-2, God created the perfect earth. Man had everything he could want or need. In fact, man/woman would never experience a physical death or any type of eternal death while living under the rule and reign of God in this perfect place.

But problems arose when man/woman were deceived by Satan into thinking they could be just like God. This deception led them to doubt God and eat of the forbidden fruit.

Genesis 3: 1-7
Now the serpent was more crafty than any of the wild animals the Lord God had made. He said to the woman, “Did God really say, ‘You must not eat from any tree in the garden’? ”
 
2 The woman said to the serpent, “We may eat fruit from the trees in the garden,

3 but God did say, ‘You must not eat fruit from the tree that is in the middle of the garden, and you must not touch it, or you will die.’” 

4 “You will not certainly die,” the serpent said to the woman.

 5 “For God knows that when you eat from it your eyes will be opened, and you will be like God, knowing good and evil.”

6 When the woman saw that the fruit of the tree was good for food and pleasing to the eye, and also desirable for gaining wisdom, she took some and ate it. She also gave some to her husband, who was with her, and he ate it.

7 Then the eyes of both of them were opened, and they realized they were naked; so they sewed fig leaves together and made coverings for themselves. 

Genesis 3: 8-13 , 16-24
8 Then the man and his wife heard the sound of the Lord God as he was walking in the garden in the cool of the day, and they hid from the Lord God among the trees of the garden. 

 9 But the Lord God called to the man, “Where are you?” 

10 He answered, “I heard you in the garden, and I was afraid because I was naked; so I hid.”

11 And he said, “Who told you that you were naked? Have you eaten from the tree that I commanded you not to eat from? ”

12 The man said, “The woman you put here with me —she gave me some fruit from the tree, and I ate it.”

13 Then the Lord God said to the woman, “What is this you have done?” The woman said, “The serpent deceived me, and I ate.”

16 To the woman he said,
“I will make your pains in childbearing very severe;
    with painful labor you will give birth to children.
Your desire will be for your husband,
    and he will rule over you. ”

17 To Adam he said, “Because you listened to your wife and ate fruit from the tree about which I commanded you, ‘You must not eat from it,’
“Cursed is the ground because of you;
    through painful toil you will eat food from it
    all the days of your life.

18 It will produce thorns and thistles for you,
    and you will eat the plants of the field.

19 By the sweat of your brow
    you will eat your food
until you return to the ground,
    since from it you were taken;
for dust you are
    and to dust you will return.” 

20 Adam named his wife Eve, because she would become the mother of all the living.

21 The Lord God made garments of skin for Adam and his wife and clothed them. 

  22 And the Lord God said, “The man has now become like one of us, knowing good and evil. He must not be allowed to reach out his hand and take also from the tree of life and eat, and live forever.” 

  23 So the Lord God banished him from the Garden of Eden to work the ground from which he had been taken. 

 24 After he drove the man out, he placed on the east side of the Garden of Eden cherubim and a flaming sword flashing back and forth to guard the way to the tree of life. 





    Humanity had sinned against God and they were banished from Eden (the perfect place) and had to live the life of toiling the land for themselves.  Life would no longer continue to be easy, with the fallen world before them.

    Ever since this time, man has been trying to return to Eden with his own plan, a plan based on deception. Carnal man continues to believe he can be like God, knowing for himself what is good and what is evil. Humanity continues to be deceived by the father of lies and the great deceiver Satan. One day God will bring His people back to the Garden of Eden, but it will be under His terms and in His timing. Human efforts to construct UTOPIA have always failed and will continue to fail. UTOPIA is defined as a place of ideal perfection, especially in laws, government, and social conditions.




    ONE

    As utopianism has evolved over the centuries, two false beliefs about human nature have been woven into our society.

    The first is the belief that people are equal, not just in the way as described by the Declaration of Independence. Equality, as understood by our American Founders, is the natural right of every individual to live freely under self-government, to acquire and retain the property he creates through his own labor, and to be treated impartially before a just law. The utopians type of equality is known as egalitarianism. In the “fair society”, it is believed that different groups of people (men, women, blacks, whites, heterosexuals, homosexuals, children of the poor, children of the rich, etc)  will naturally have the same distribution of outcomes in life. That is having the same arithmetical mean with regards to income, educational attainment, number of truck drivers, number of CEO's, etc. This equality of outcomes is advanced as being just, fair, and virtuous. When this does not happen, it must be due to bad human behavior and an unfair society. In the last 40 to 50 years in our country, this premise of setting up a “level field” has justified millions of pages of government regulations, unending legislation, and exorbitant amounts of money.

    The second of the beliefs about human nature is that human beings are not really responsible for the things they do. People who do well do not really deserve what they have gotten. People who do badly do not deserve it either. Thus it is morally appropriate to require the economically successful to hand over most of what they have earned to the state, and the state will redistribute the wealth as the state believes is just.

    The great crime of the utopian ideal is that failure for this system to solve problems and even expand the problems is never the fault of the idea or the “masterminds.” What's always needed is more control and more time to eradicate past history and influences. The federal government of the United States of America spent about $1.5 trillion in transfer payments last year. This includes Social Security, Medicare, and all forms of individual and corporate welfare. The states spent another few billion dollars in transfer payments. And yet, we still have millions in need and very few problems resolved.

    Utopianism is not new. It has been repackaged countless times – since the days of Plato and before. Plato's Republic, Thomas Moore's Utopia, Thomas Hobbes' Leviathan, and Karl Marx's The Communist Manifesto are indispensable in understanding the nature of utopianism.  All have common soul-less societies that are absorbed into a cesspool of oppressive and absolute power.




    TWO

    Plato was not the first but was the most prominent of the earliest philosophers to develop a utopian state model. Plato's Republic was written in 380 BC. Applying his notions of a just society, Plato claimed to construct an ideal city through a fictional dialogue with Socrates and others. What he actually created was a totalitarian state.

    The Republic's influence on future philosophers and societies is clear. It is not difficult to find the organisms of Marxism, National Socialism, and other forms of utopianism in the Republic. Plato's city provides ONLY for the most basic needs of its citizens (food, shelter, clothing, and shoes). It is constructed on a simple division of labor where each individual does a single job based on his greatest skill set.  Each individual accepts his position in the city and does what he is supposed to do for the benefit of himself and the other citizens. According to Plato, he will do this because his basic needs are met. This ideal city does not have any luxuries, such as furniture, entertainment, and meat.

    Plato acknowledges that this most basic city is not one in which many will find complete satisfaction. Therefore, he constructs another ideal city, which he describes as having high excitement and luxury. His new city promotes the individual's subservience to the state. The state will be in complete control of private property, health care, the workforce, housing, and more. It establishes a strict class system and uses eugenics, euthanasia, arranged marriages, and the ongoing indoctrination of the masses to maintain unity in this “just society.”

    This society is built on a foundation of falsehoods, propaganda, and censorship. Plato's intention is to create an aristocratic ruling class of philosophers (Guardians) who will rule wisely and guide the city. Of course, there is little to prevent the ruling class from abusing its power and ruling on its own behalf, as history has demonstrated time and time again. The Guardians are to be a pure race of leaders, originally bred from the best citizens.

    In order to build wealth and to enlarge its borders, Plato argues that the city must have the capacity to make war with neighboring cities. A warrior class of Auxiliaries must be cultivated. They will be trained to be aggressive and ruthless, but must also be controlled as to keep them gentle towards the citizens of the city. The Auxiliaries are to serve the Guardians.

    Plato invents a “noble lie” that is taught from the early ages that each person is born of the earth rather than from a mother. Each individual is said to be born with a particular metal – gold, silver, or bronze- that is intermingled in his/her body. The metal will determine the person's status and relative worth in the City. Gold souled citizens are the Guardians, the silver souled are the Auxiliaries, and the bronze souled are the Producers (actually treated more like slaves). The city's unity and stability require that its citizens be conditioned to accept their positions and surrender their personal desires to the needs of the city. Individuals are conditioned to suppress their personal desires and competitive spirit in favor of acting for the common good.

    In Plato's just city, the nuclear family is abolished. Men, women, and children will live communally. Soon after birth the children are removed from their mothers to be raised and educated collectively. The city replaces parents and their contemporaries become brothers and sisters. The purpose is to create a single extended family- the city itself. Supposedly the individual will become loyal and reliant on the city, thereby eliminating competitiveness between city and family.

    Owning private property will be forbidden for everyone, including the Guardian class. Having a community of property and the community of families will prevent tearing the city into pieces by individuals quarreling about “mine and not mine.”

    Indoctrination is also crucial to controlling the citizenry. The city consists of a comprehensive “education” system. In addition to the noble lie, censorship is widely practiced. For example, myths and music are suppressed in the city to avoid any stories where authority is challenged or the Guardians are presented as anything other than good. Freedom of expression is banned, for the city's health is more important than self-expression.

    Having eliminated family ties, independent thought, and individual dignity, Plato turns to the city's standards for medical ethics. Only those who are otherwise healthy, but suffer a minor injury or seasonal malady, are entitled to health care. The chronically ill are not beneficial to the city and will not be treated. The old and the infirmed are also denied treatment. “No one has the leisure to be sick throughout life” and should not benefit from the “invention of lingering death.” Plato also proposes state-imposed euthanasia for appropriate cases as determined by the Guardian ruling class.

     
    In Plato's Republic, the term “Good” is ultimate truth. In his view, understanding the Good is beyond the capabilities of the vast majority of people. Consequently, the city must be ruled by Guardians who are the only people able to discern the Good. Only the Guardians can make judgments about what constitutes a “Good person”, a “Good life”, or a “Good death.” In Plato's city, the individual is indentured to the state. Justice is synonymous with the well-being of the city.

    In a peculiar turn of events, Plato admits that this just and wise city is impossible to create, and even if created, would be impossible to maintain, given man's imperfections. Plato even admits that a democracy is the fairest and freest of all systems, but argues that freedom and fairness without education and discipline is a recipe for disaster. The majority of citizens will become undisciplined and easily seduced by unnecessary desires (on this he may have a valid point).

    Plato prophetically illustrates his concerns toward democracy with familiar examples. Parents treat their children as contemporaries, who in turn will disrespect and disobey their parents as a sign of freedom. Teachers flatter their students out of fear and the students disrespect their teachers. The citizens begin to resist any touch of authority and cease to care even for the laws, written or unwritten. Plato warns that the excesses that dominate a democracy will lead the undisciplined majority to become drunk with freedom. As a result, the rulers must constantly strive to please the citizens. He could easily be describing the United States of America in this current age.

    Plato states, eventually a great champion will appear whom the people willingly “set over them and nurse into greatness.” He is seen as the citizen's protector. He is the ultimate populist, but in fact is a demagogue (the great panderer of people). Plato warns that this protector will become obsessed with power, the consolidation of power, and the preservation of power. He loses sight of the community's well being and can only see himself. Finally, he seizes absolute power as a political tyrant and the city becomes the most miserable of cities.

    Plato has become the pioneer of many propagandists who, often in good faith, developed the technique of appealing to the moral and humanitarian sentiments for immoral and anti-humanitarian purposes. Plato provided a philosophical and intellectual brew for a utopian society that would influence tyrannies for centuries to come.


    THREE


    The word UTOPIA was coined by Sir Thomas More, a noted British lawyer, lord chancellor under King Henry VIII, and since recognized as a saint in the Catholic Church.

    More created utopia as the centerpiece of his novel having the same name, in 1516. Throughout the underlying contention of his narrative is that a society in which every need is answered and every want is either met or made, results in a near perfect existence.

    In Utopia, More creates the outline of a representative governmental structure which becomes fully irrelevant as the details of his utopia are planned to every minute detail. The details of his model are listed:
    • No travel within city limits or beyond without a passport.
    • There will be no such thing as private property.
    • All homes will be identical.
    • Utopia's economic egalitarianism (equal rights, opportunities, and outcomes) requires everyone to turn in everything they produce over to the central storehouses, from which they will receive whatever they need to live (as determined by the governing authority).
    • Currency is banned from the island nation of Utopia.
    • The work day schedule is pre-determined by the ruling authority. 6 hour workdays are mandatory along with a mandatory 2 hour siesta to follow lunch.
    • Bedtime for everyone is 8 pm. Everyone must sleep for 8 hours each evening.
    • Utopians are expected to pursue the hobbies or avocations of interest to them, but those interests must contribute to the greater good of society.
    • Meals are taken communally at appointed times in a great hall that is located in each neighborhood.
    • All people will wear identical clothing.
    • Every religion on the island must recognize a single, supreme, ever present god. Each religion worships in a way that would not be derogative to the other religions. No image of any god is to be seen in a church. All religions will use the same name for god (Mythra) and all agree that Mythra represents the divine majesty, whatever or whomever it must be. 
    • Health care is free. Hospitals are so lavish and well equipped that all citizens of Utopia would rather lie in a hospital than at home.
    • Individuals who suffer from incurable diseases or fatal conditions and are no longer of use to society, are encouraged to commit suicide to ease their pain and alleviate their burden upon civilization.
    *I find peculiar how Thomas More was canonized in the Catholic Church with his views of God and suicide.
     
    More's response to evil, injustice, and inequalities throughout the world was to fabricate an egalitarian society that claims to provide for all the wants and needs on an equal basis by expunging humanness from the human being and suppressing individual pride (free will and personal fulfillment) for the good of society. In Utopia the individual is not trusted to care for himself. His highest value is that of an insipid (lacking flavor) worker who compliantly obeys orders.

    Apart from its religious component, this form of utopianism is a forerunner to the “utopian socialism” as recognized in The Communist Manifesto and its emphasis on radical egalitarianism. It substitutes one evil for another. Like Plato's Republic, Utopia suppresses man's nature instead of nurturing it. Thomas More does not adequately represent the magnitude of coercion, repression, and punishment that would be needed to impose order in this society that has so many intricate rules. Mao Zedong's Great Leap Forward was supposed to be modeled as More's Utopia, but the police-state tactics used to generate society rules resulted in the death of millions of Chinese people.


    FOUR


    Thomas Hobbes, a friend of English royalty, fled from France in 1651 due to the general anarchy that existed in Europe. He wrote Leviathan which was influenced by what he observed and experienced.

    His work concerns the structure of society and legitimate government, and is regarded as one of the earliest and most influential examples of social contract theory. Social contract theory addresses two questions. First, what is the origin of society. Second, is the legitimacy of the state over the individual.

    In Leviathan, which was written during the English Civil War, Hobbes argues for a social contract and rule by an absolute sovereign. He argued that men live in constant fear, anxiety, and conflict. Because of this they could not be trusted to govern themselves. He felt a “Sovereign” must be given absolute power over the subjects to protect them from themselves and outside invaders. In Hobbes Leviathan, the Sovereign was a totalitarian state with a vast bureaucracy controlling the lives of its subjects.

    Only by transferring all rights to the Sovereign could men live in peace, stability, and contentment. The rights to be transferred included control of the judicial system (the Sovereign would determine right from wrong), control of free will (the Sovereign would determine what subjects could do or not do), control of possessions (the Sovereign would determine the goods each subject could enjoy), control of the distribution of materials (such as land), and control over foreign trade. This relationship was described by Hobbes as a social contract between subjects and the Sovereign.

    Hobbes argued that all men are equal in the sense that they all must strive for survival. In the nature of man, he found three principal causes of quarrel: competition, distrust, and lust for glory. Thus men are led by their natural instincts to invade for gain, fight for safety, and dominate for their reputations. Hobbes concluded that the natural state of man was essentially being in a state of war.

    To separate man from his warlike nature, all men must renounce all of their presumed rights and transfer it to a powerful Sovereign. Once that transfer has occurred, the subject is in no position to hinder the Sovereign's rights to do as it desires. According to Hobbes, when the covenant between the subjects and the Sovereign is made, to break it is unjust. The definition of injustice is simply not performing the requirements of the covenant. And whatever is NOT unjust, IS just.

    Man requires a power to keep him fearful and in awe. This will restrain the subjects from acting upon their natural tendencies. Thus it is necessary to create a common power to defend men from others who want to harm them, and to provide security so they can live in peace. This requires that they all must “confer all their power and strength upon one man or an assembly of men, they must reduce their wills, unto one will...and must submit themselves to the Sovereign's will and judgements.”

    The Sovereign power would be obtained in one of two ways: men voluntarily agreeing to submit to a man or submitting to an assembly of men by Natural Force.

    In Hobbes Utopia, the rights of the Sovereign are nearly absolute:
    • Subjects can not change the form of government.
    • Sovereign power can not be forfeited.
    • Since the majority has declared the Sovereign, the minority must consent to the Sovereign actions.
    • The Sovereign's actions can not be challenged by the subjects as being unjust.
    • Whatever the Sovereign does is “nonpunishable” by the subjects.
    • The Sovereign is the sole judge as to what is averse or beneficial to the Commonwealth.
    • The Sovereign has the whole power to determine the rules by which all subjects are to live.
    • The Sovereign controls the judicial system.
    • The Sovereign is the Commander in Chief who decides when to wage war and against whom.
    • The Sovereign will choose as it sees fit all the members of the governmental ruling class.
    • The Sovereign can award or punish according to the laws it has made.

    Hobbes does recognize that the subjects may envision evil consequences of placing absolute power in the Sovereign authority. But according to him, the consequences of natural man remaining unchecked is much worse. He naively believes that the individual would willingly surrender his rights and liberties to an all-powerful, centralized mastermind whom he INSISTS will behave prudently and judiciously. That is Hobbes being certain that his society will be governed by the “benevolent dictator.” How many times has that false hope endured in the history of the world?

    Hobbes creates a false choice between polar opposites. Either live in anarchy or live under despotism. He assumes most people would choose despotism. As in the Republic and Utopia, absolute power over the individual requires a far-reaching police state. As in most tyrannies, the individual's liberty will undoubtedly and steadily constrict and erode. Such is the nature of giving man or an assembly of men absolute power. Throughout history, unspeakable misery and violence have been perpetrated by tyrants in the name of the greater and the common good

    From Leviathan springs not a virtuous government that is protective of the civil society, but a totalitarian regime. As with Plato and More, Hobbes rejects self-government because he believes the individual man can not be trusted to govern themselves. Thus he designs another utopian regime, led by man with absolute powers that totally devours the individual.


    FIVE


    In 1848, on behalf of the Communist League, Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels completed The Communist Manifesto. This work set the foundation for the international communist movement. Marx and Engels saw society as being split up into two great hostile camps, into two great classes that directly face each other. That is the Bourgeois (capitalists) and the Proletariat (laborers).

    The bourgeoisie, according to Marx, in the search for expanding markets and revenue was establishing itself into all portions of the globe. In order to diminish the harmful effects of the bourgeois, they needed to be rid of their material wealth. In a sense, the overlying theory of communism is based on the “abolition of private property.”

    For Marx and Engel, to defeat the bourgeois it would be crucial to sever all ties with the past, as the past is nothing more than a history of domination over the proletariat. Within any communist society, the present always is dominant over the past.

    The communists also reject completely the concept of natural law and right reason as this would allow the perpetuation of bourgeois control over the proletariat. Because the family structure grew out of bourgeois material needs, all family ties must be dissolved for the good of the greater community. Breaking from the past and breaking up families means a break from tradition, customs, institutions, religion, and requires that education be replaced with communist indoctrination. Communism in its truest form, abolishes eternal truths, all religion, and all morality versus constituting them into a different form.

    The Communist revolution is a radical rupturing of all traditional values and ideas. Communism foresees a successful working-class revolution that replaces the bourgeois as the ruling class. 

    Communists will then use all their political supremacy to confiscate all capital from the bourgeois, and centralize all instruments of production into the hands of the state and to increase the total of production as rapidly as possible.

    Once the state is under the control of the proletariat, its objective will generally include the following ten tenets:
    • Abolition of property in land and application of all rents of land to public purposes.
    • A heavy progressive or graduated income tax.
    • Abolition of the right of inheritance.
    • Centralization of the property of all emigrants and rebels.
    • Centralization of credit in the hands of the state, by means of a national bank with state capital and with exclusive monopoly.
    • Centralization of all means of communication and transportation into the hands of the state.
    • Equal liability of all workers to labor. Industrial armies are established to work on farms.
    • Centralization of all factories and farms.
    • A more equitable distribution of the population over the country.
    • Free education for all children in public schools.




    Marx and Engel have this revelation that communism and the workers' paradise is preordained. Their ideas, according to them, are not an invention, discovery, or a type of reform. In their naive or twisted minds they believe that communism is an absolute certainty and can not be obstructed by law or politics.

    Marx believes that after all remnants of the bourgeois society have been eliminated, having been replaced with a classless workers paradise, the centralized and all powerful state will simply wither away. Mr. Marx, we are still waiting!

    For their ideas of a classless state to materialize, a re-set button must be pushed. There must be a complete break from the past and a cleansing of any memory of past societies. There can not be any remnants of what was and what is.

    It is one thing to espouse views about man's historic class and economic struggles and predict the future, but another to make the fantasy tangible.  Marx has no scheme allowing for the development of institutions and mechanics to bring it all to reality. Even Vladimir Lenin was quick to realize that Marx's ideas were of no help in matters of practical economics.

    To say that man exists in essentially one of two conditions- a bourgeois or a proletariat that is being exploited by the former is erroneous to the highest degree. As stated a half-century ago by French philosopher Raymond Aron, “To declare that a worker in a capitalist factory in France or the United States is by definition exploited and that a worker in a Soviet factory is not,..... is pure nonsense.

    Marx and Engels fantasy is full of holes that can not be explained. Once the absolute power or supreme party has taken hold, to voluntarily surrender this power and wither away is not practical. In fact, the way this transformation would take place is not even addressed in The Communist Manifesto.

    The history and nature of all communist governments is that they ultimately become totalitarian regimes. The only thing that withers away are individual liberties and rights. The impact of the illogical writings of Marx and Engel have been enormous and devastating. One hundred years of communist tyranny and mass genocide have not deterred the lunatic fanatics from clinging to their vision of Utopia. In their mind, the failure of communism is found in the man and men who bastardize it, not in the dogma. True communism, they argue, has never been fully executed. After all, the workers paradise is inevitable.


    SIX

    In all four types of Utopia, the individual and his family are subservient to the state. Society would become a better place if man would change his nature to accommodate the utopian ideal. Since left to his own natural devices, man will not oblige and must be made to do so. Out of this the “masterminds” are born- both the revolutionaries and the rulers. To rise above “the masses”, for unlike the rest of us, they are self-evidently altruistic, prudent, virtuous, and wise. Whether or not they know how to run their own lives or the lives of others.

    The utopians have a dangerous illusion that by depriving individuals of the power they posses in an individualistic system, and transferring this power to society, that they are extinguishing the power of those over them.  Overlooked is that by concentrating power so that it can be used in the service of a single plan, not only transfers that power but infinitely expands it.  Power in the hands of a single body is infinitely greater than the power that existed before.

    In a competitive society, no one person can exercise even a fraction of the power in which a sovereign would possess.  Consider the power that your millionaire employer may have over you?  In the "free" and "individualistic" society you always have the option of removing yourself from the condition you may detest.  But, the power of one single bureaucrat within a sovereign regime can enslave you into a situation of which you have no freedom or control.  That freedom has been taken away from the individual for the good of the state.

    The system of private property is the most important guarantee of freedom, not only to those who own property, but as important to those who don't.  Because control of what we own, what we produce, and what we accumulate is divided among many people acting independently that we as individuals can decide for ourselves how we will manage our lives.

    When the sovereign power undertakes a plan to confiscate and deliver the wealth, by what principles are they guided?  Is there really a definite answer?  What formula is used in deciding the taking from whom and distribution to whom else?  All the masterminds really say is they want to take from the rich as much as they can.  I ask, what is the definition of "rich?"


    The utopians promise a freedom from economic care, which can only be obtained by relieving us of the power of choice.  Economic freedom can only be that freedom of economic activity which, together with the right choice, carries also the risk and responsibility of that right.

    America's heritage and lineage dates back hundreds of years before the American Revolution and transcends all else. From the earliest of settlers escaping persecution or seeking opportunities in the New World, to the original colonies asserting self-rule through popular sovereignty and numerous local governing bodies.  From the demand for independence and assertion of inalienable rights, to the founding of the constitutional republic to secure individual liberty and the civil society, the American people engaged in the most widely considered and far reaching exploration of humanity in world history.

    When the 55 delegates met in Philadelphia in 1787 at the Constitutional Convention, their purpose was not to transform American society but to preserve and protect it. In Federalist 51, James Madison explained their task in this way: “But what is government itself, but the greatest reflections on human nature? If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary. In framing a government which is said to be administered by men over men, the great difficulty lies in this: you must first enable the government to control the governed and in the next place oblige itself to control itself.”

    The greatest fear of the delegates at the constitutional and state conventions would be the concentration of too much power in the new federal government. Not only was there little support for an all-powerful central government, but the delegates at the Constitutional Convention of 1787 spent most of the summer trying to figure out how to ensure that no office or office holder in the new federal government would become too powerful.

    In order to secure the Constitution's ratification, the Federalists eventually agreed to introduce a set of amendments in the 1st Congress, further delineating and underscoring the limits of the federal government respecting its potential abuse against the individual and usurpation of the states. The amendments became the Bill of Rights.

    The underlying factors and values that make possible the civil society, which center on the liberty and rights of the individual, have been and are being devitalized and stifled by utopian masterminds who substitute their own preferences, objectives, and decisions for a free people. The means in which these utopians amass their power is through the federal government. The federal government has been detached from its original intent. As a result, America today is not strictly a constitutional republic, because the Constitution has been and continues to be easily altered by a judicial oligarchy (governed by few) that mostly enforces, if not expands, federal power. It is not strictly a representative republic, because so many edicts are produced by a maze of administrative departments that are unknown to the public and kept out of view so the public has no understanding of the intent and consequences. We are not strictly a federal republic any longer in that the states that gave central government life now live at it's behest.

    In America, the wealthy can fall and do, and the poor can rise and do. There has been an immense prosperity born of an open society and economic market system that knows no class structure. The false utopianism intruding our society incites jealousy among some, if not many, divides and distracts the people, and furthers the prospects of mastermind control by changing society's psychology and national character.

    The American founding was an EXCEPTIONAL exercise in collective human virtue and wisdom, a culmination of thousands of years of experience, knowledge, reason, and faith. The Declaration of Independence and our Constitution are our “Dream”, our “Experiment”, and our “EXCEPTIONALISM”.

    I pray not that we follow the path prophesied by Benjamin Franklin when he stated in his elderly years that “the Constitution is likely to be well administered for a Course of Years, and can only end up in Despotism and other such Forms have done before it, when the People shall become corrupt as to need Despotic Government, being incapable of any other....”





    CONCLUSION


    Exodus 20: 3-6

    3 “You shall have no other gods before me.

    4 “You shall not make for yourself an image in the form of anything in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the waters below. 
      
    5 You shall not bow down to them or worship them; for I, the Lord your God, am a jealous God, punishing the children for the sin of the parents to the third and fourth generation of those who hate me,  

    6 but showing love to a thousand generations of those who love me and keep my commandments.



    Revelation 11:15


    15 The seventh angel sounded his trumpet, and there were loud voices in heaven, which said:
    “The kingdom of the world has become
        the kingdom of our Lord and of his Messiah,
        and he will reign for ever and ever.” 






    I choose death over replacing God with man to be the Sovereign power in my life.


    My continual prayer is that we, peoples of the United States of America, will remain prosperous and free until King Jesus comes again.