Culture

CULTURE.......

Language
: the oldest human institution and the most sophisticated medium of expression.

Arts & Sciences : the most advanced and refined forms of human expression.

Thought : the ways in which people perceive, interpret, and understand the world around them.

Spirituality : the value system transmitted through generations for the inner well-being of human beings, expressed through language and actions.

Social activities : the shared pursuits within a cultural community, demonstrated in a variety of festivities and life-celebrating events.

Interaction : the social aspects of human contact, including the give-and-take of socialization, negotiation, protocols, and conventions.

Sunday, March 24, 2013

MARRIAGE: What it is, Why it matters, and the Consequences of Redefining It




 This piece is an edited and shortened version of an article written by Ryan T. Anderson.

Ryan T. Anderson researches and writes about marriage and religious liberty as the William E. Simon Fellow in Religion and a Free Society at The Heritage Foundation. He also focuses on justice and moral principles in economic thought, health care and education, and has expertise in bioethics and natural law theory.


His articles have appeared in The Wall Street Journal, First Things, Weekly Standard, National Review, Ricochet.com, New Atlantis, Claremont Review of Books, Touchstone, Books and Culture, Christianity Today, The City and Human Life Review.

Anderson received his bachelor of arts degree from Princeton University, graduating Phi Beta Kappa and magna cum laude. He is a doctoral candidate in political philosophy at the University of Notre Dame, where he received his master’s degree. His research spans the natural law tradition in conversation with classical and contemporary liberalism. The tentative title of his dissertation: “Beyond Private Property and Social Welfare: Economic Justice and Economic Rights.”

At the heart of the current debates about same-sex marriage are three crucial questions:  What is marriage, why does marriage matter for public policy, and what would be the consequences of redefining marriage to exclude sexual complementarity?

Marriage exists to bring a man and a woman together as husband and wife to be father and mother to any children their union produces.  It is based on the anthropological truth that men and women are different and complementary, the biological fact that reproduction depends on a man and a woman, and the social reality that children need both a mother and a father.  Marriage predates government.  It is the fundamental building block of all human civilization.  Marriage has public purposes that transcend private purposes.  This is why 41 states, with good reason, affirm that marriage is between a man and a woman.

Government recognizes marriage because it is an institution that benefits society in a way that no other relationship does.  Marriage is society's least restrictive means of ensuring the well-being of children.  While representing everyone's liberty, government rightly recognizes, protects, and promotes marriage as the ideal institution for childbearing and childrearing.

Promoting marriage as between man and woman does not ban any type of relationship.  Adults are free to make choices about their relationships, and they do not need government sanction or license to do so.  All Americans have the freedom to live as they choose, but no one has a right to redefine marriage for everyone else.

In recent decades, marriage has been weakened by a revisionist view that is more about adults' desires than a children's needs.  This reduces marriage to a system to approve emotional bonds or distribute legal privileges.

Redefining marriage to include same-sex relationships is the culmination of this revisionism, and it would leave emotional intensity as the only thing that sets marriage apart from other bonds.  Redefining marriage would legislate a new principle that marriage is whatever emotional bond the government says it is.

Redefining marriage does not simply expand the existing understanding of marriage.  It rejects the anthropological truth that marriage is based on the complementarity of man and woman, the biological fact that reproduction depends on man and a woman, and the social reality that children need a mother and a father.  Concerns for the common good requires protecting and strengthening marriage culture by promoting truth about marriage.

WHAT IS MARRIAGE? 

Marriage exists to bring a man and a woman together as husband and wife to be father and mother to any children their union produces.    

When a baby is born, there is always a mother nearby:  That is a fact of reproductive biology.  The question is whether a father will be involved in the life of that child and, if so, for how long.  Marriage increases the odds that a man will be committed to both the children that he helps create and the woman with whom he does so.

Marriage connects people and goods that otherwise tend to fragment.  It helps to connect sex with love, men with women, sex with babies, and babies with moms and dads.  Social, cultural, and legal signals and pressures can support or detract from the role of marriage in this regard.

Marriage is a uniquely comprehensive union.  In short, marriage unites a man and a woman holistically - emotionally and bodily, in acts of conjugal love and in the children such love brings forth - for the whole of life.

In reality, there is no such thing as "parenting".  There is mothering and there is fathering, and children do best with both.  While men and women are each capable of providing their children with a good upbringing, there are, on average, differences in the ways that mothers and fathers interact with their children and the functional roles that they play.

According to Rutgers University sociologist David Popenoe:

"We should disavow the notion that "mommies can make good daddies," just as we should disavow the popular notion that "daddies make good mommies."  The two sexes are different to the core, and each is necessary - culturally and biologically - for the optimal development of a human being."  

Marriage is the fundamental building block of all human civilization.  The government does not create marriage.  Marriage is a natural institution that predates government.  Society as a whole, not merely any given set of spouses, benefits from marriage.  This is because marriage helps to channel procreative love into a stable institution that provides for the orderly bearing and rearing of the next generation.

This understanding of marriage as the union of man and woman is shared by the Jewish, Christian, and Muslim traditions; by ancient Greek and Roman thinkers untouched by these religions; and by various Enlightenment philosophers.  The union of husband and wife arose in many places, over several centuries, in which same-sex marriage was nowhere on the radar.  Indeed, it arose in cultures that had no concept of sexual orientation and in some that fully accepted homoeroticism.

As with other public policy issues, religious voices on marriage should be welcomed in the public square.  Yet one not need appeal to distinctively religious arguments to understand why marriage - as a natural institution - is the union of man and woman.

WHY MARRIAGE MATTERS FOR POLICY   

Virtually every political community has regulated male-female sexual relationships.  This is not due to the fact that government cares about romance.  Government recognizes male-female sexual relationships because these alone produce new human beings.  For highly dependent infants, there is no path to physical, moral, and cultural maturity (personal responsibility) without a long and delicate process of ongoing care and supervision to which mothers and fathers bring unique gifts.  Unless children mature, they never will become healthy, upright, productive members of society.  Marriage exists to make men and women responsible to each other and to any children that they might have.

Sociologist James Q. Wilson wrote:

"Marriage is a socially arranged solution for the problem of getting people to stay together and care for children that the mere desire for children, and the sex that makes children possible, does not solve."  

Marriage is society's least restrictive means of ensuring the well-being of children.  Government regulation of marriage protects children by incentivizing men and women to commit to each other and take responsibility for their children.

Social science confirms the importance of marriage for children.  According to the best available sociological evidence, children fare best on virtually every examined indicator when reared by their wedded biological parents.  Studies that control for other factors, including poverty and even genetics, suggest that children reared in intact homes do best on educational achievement, emotional health, familial and sexual development, and delinquency and incarceration.

Father's matter and marriage helps to connect fathers to mothers and children.  Social science claiming to show that there are "no differences" in outcomes for children raised in same-sex households does not change this reality.  In fact, the most recent and sophisticated studies suggest that prior research is inadequate to support the assertion that it makes "no difference" whether a child was raised by same-sex partners.  A survey of 59 of the most prominent studies often cited for this claim shows that they drew primarily from small convenience samples that are not appropriate for generalizations to the whole population.

Meanwhile, recent studies using rigorous methods and robust samples confirm that children do better when raised by a married mother and father.  These include the New Family Structures Study by Professor Mark Regenerus at the University of Texas - Austin and a report based on Census data recently released in the highly respected journal Demography.  

Marriage benefits everyone because separating childbearing and childrearing from marriage burdens innocent bystanders; not just the children but the whole community.  More often than not, the community must step in to provide for their well-being and upbringing.  Thus, by encouraging marriage norms of monogamy, sexual exclusivity, and permanence, the state is strengthening civil society and reducing its own role.

A recent summary by Professor W. Bradford Wilcox of Virginia's National Marriage Project highlights the benefits:

"The core message....is that the wealth of nations depends in no small part on the health of the family.....marriage plays an underappreciated and important role in fostering long term economic growth, the viability of the welfare, the size and quality of the workforce, and the health of large sectors of the modern economy."

Given its economic benefits, it is no surprise that the decline of marriage most hurts the least well-off.  A leading indicator of whether someone will know poverty or prosperity is whether, growing up, he/she knew the love and security of having a married mother and father.  A recent report points out, "Being raised in a married family reduced a childs probability of living in poverty by about 82%.

While respecting everyone's liberty, government rightly recognizes, protects, and promotes marriage as the ideal institution for childbearing and childrearing.  Adults are free to make choices about their relationships without redefining marriage and do not need government sanction or license to do so.

*Important

Government is not in the business of affirming our love.  Rather, it leaves consenting adults free to live and love as they choose.  Contrary to what some say, there is no ban on same-sex marriage.  Nothing about it is illegal.  In all 50 states, two people of the same sex may choose to live together, choose to join a religious community that blesses their relationship, and choose a workplace offering joint benefits.  There is nothing illegal about this. 

What is at issue is whether the government will recognize such relationships as marriage - and then force every citizen, house of worship, and business to do so as well.  At issue is whether policy will coerce and compel others to recognize and affirm same-sex relationships as marriages.  All Americans have the freedom to live as they choose, but they do not have the right to redefine marriage for everyone else.


 THE CONSEQUENCES OF REDEFINING MARRIAGE

Redefining marriage would further disconnect childbearing from marriage.  That would hurt children, especially the most vulnerable.  It would deny as a matter of policy the ideal that children need a mother and a father.  Traditional marriage laws reinforce the idea that a married mother and father is the most appropriate environment for rearing children, as the best available social science suggests.

Recognizing same-sex relationships as marriages would legally abolish that ideal.  It would deny the significance of both mothering and fathering to children; that boys and girls tend to benefit from fathers and mothers in different ways.  Indeed, the law, public schools, and media would teach that mothers and fathers are fully interchangeable and that thinking otherwise is bigoted.

Leading LGBT advocates admit that redefining marriage changes its meaning.  E.J. Graff celebrates the fact that redefining marriage would change the "institution's message" so that it would "ever after stand for sexual choice, for cutting the link between sex and diapers."  Enacting same-sex marriage, she argues, "does more than just fit; it announces that marriage has changed shape."  

Government should exist to create the conditions under which individuals and freely formed communities can thrive.  The most important free community - the one on which all others depend - is the marriage based family.  The conditions for its thriving include the accommodations and pressures that marriage law provides for couples to stay together.  Redefining marriage would further erode marital norms, thrusting government further into leading roles for which it is poorly suited; parent and discipliner to the orphaned; provider to the neglected; and arbiter of disputes over custody, paternity, and visitation.  As the family weakens, welfare programs and correctional bureaucracies would grow.

Redefining marriage to include same-sex relationships is not ultimately about expanding the pool of people who are eligible to marry.  Redefining marriage is about cementing a new idea of marriage into the law - an idea whose baleful effects conservatives have fought for years.  The idea that romantic-emotional union is all that makes a marriage cannot explain or support the stabilizing norms that make marriage fitting for for family life.  It can only undermine those norms.

Redefining marriage would abandon the norm of male-female sexual conplementarity as an essential characteristic of marriage.  Making that optional would also make other essential characteristics of marriage - such as monogamy, exclusivity, and permanency optional.

New York University Professor Judith Stacey has expressed hope that redefining marriage would give marriage "varied, creative, and adaptive contours," leading some to question the limitations of Western marriage and seek....small group marriages."  In their statement "Beyond Same-Sex Marriage," more than 300 LGBT and allied scholars and advocates call for legally recognizing sexual relationships involving more than two partners.

Andrew Sullivan, who has extolled the spirituality of anonymous sex, also thinks that the openness of same-sex unions could enhance the bonds of husbands and wives:

"Same-sex unions often incorporate the virtues of friendship more effectively than traditional marriages; and at times, among gay male relationships, the openness of the contract makes it more likely to survive than many heterosexual bonds...There is more likely to be greater understanding of the need for extra-marital outlets between two men than between a man and a woman...Something of the gay relationship's necessary honesty, its flexibility, and its equality could undoubtedly help strengthen and inform many heterosexual bonds."        

Openness and flexibility are Sullivan's euphemisms for sexual infidelity.

Some advocates of redefining marriage embrace the goal of weakening the institution of marriage.  Victoria Brownsworth writes:

"..that allowing same-sex couples to marry will weaken the institution of marriage...It most certainly will do so, and that will make marriage a far better concept than it previously has been."

Professsor Ellen Willis celebrates the fact that "conferring the legitimacy of marriage on homosexual relations will introduce an implicit revolt against the institution into its very heart."  

Michelangelo Signorile urges same-sex couples to:

"demand the right to marry not as a way of adhering to society's moral codes but rather to debunk a myth and radically alter an archaic institution...Same sex couples should fight for same-sex marriage and its benefits and then, once granted, redefine the institution of marriage completely, because the most subversive action lesbians and gay men can undertake is to transform the notion of family, entirely." 


It is no surprise that there is already evidence of this occurring.  A federal judge in Utah allowed a legal challenge to anti-bigamy laws.  A bill that would allow a child to have three legal parents passed both houses of the California state legislature in 2012 before it was vetoed by the governor, who claimed he wanted to take more time to consider all the implications of this change.  The impetus of the bill was a lesbian same-sex relationship in which one partner was impregnated by a man.  The child possessed a biological mother and father, but the law recognizes the biological mother and her same-sex spouse, a "presumed mother," as the child's parents.

Redefining marriage marginalizes those with traditional views and leads to the erosion of religious liberty.  The law and culture will seek to eradicate such views through economic, social, and legal pressure.  If marriage is redefined, believing what virtually every human society once believed about marriage - a union of a man and woman ordered to procreation and family life - would be seen increasingly as a malicious prejudice to be driven to the margins of culture.  The consequences for religious believers are becoming apparent.

Thomas Messner has documented multiple instances in which redefining marriage has already become a nightmare for religious liberty.  If marriage is redefined to include same-sex relationships, then those who continue to believe the truth about marriage - that is by nature a union of man and woman - would face three different types of threats to their liberty; the administrative state, nondiscrimination law, and private actors in a culture that is now hostile to traditional views.

After Massachusetts redefined marriage to include same-sex relationships, Catholic Charities of Boston was forced to discontinue its adoption services rather than place children with same-sex couples.  Massachusetts public schools began teaching grade school students about same-sex marriage, defending their decision because they are committed to teaching about the world they live in, and in Massachusetts same-sex marriage is legal.  A Massachusetts appellate court ruled that parents have no right to exempt their children from these classes. 

The New Mexico Human Rights Commission prosecuted a photographer for declining to photograph a same-sex commitment ceremony.  Doctors in California were successfully sued for declining to perform an artificial insemination on a woman in a same-sex relationship.  Owners of a bed and breakfast in Illinois who declined to rent their facility for a same-sex civil union ceremony and reception were sued for violating the state nondiscrimination law.  A Georgia counselor was fired after she referred someone in a same-sex relationship to another counselor.  The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty reports that over 350 separate state anti-discrimination provisions would likely be triggered by recognition of same-sex marriage.