Culture

CULTURE.......

Language
: the oldest human institution and the most sophisticated medium of expression.

Arts & Sciences : the most advanced and refined forms of human expression.

Thought : the ways in which people perceive, interpret, and understand the world around them.

Spirituality : the value system transmitted through generations for the inner well-being of human beings, expressed through language and actions.

Social activities : the shared pursuits within a cultural community, demonstrated in a variety of festivities and life-celebrating events.

Interaction : the social aspects of human contact, including the give-and-take of socialization, negotiation, protocols, and conventions.

Tuesday, February 4, 2014

BOOK REVIEW: ATLAS SHRUGGED by Ayn Rand



If the reader is not intimidated by nearly 1200 pages of content,  you will be captured by the prophetic insight that Ms. Rand shares.  The book was written in the 1950's, but details with accuracy the battle that is currently taking place in our nation today.  Does redistribution of wealth and the entitlement society ring a bell in this modern age?

The themes highlighted in this book are more relevant for today than any time in our nation's history.  Ms. Rand foresaw the diminishing of individual liberties, government oppression of the self-reliant, the devaluing of accomplishment and success, and total reliance on government and central planning leaders to birth utopia in the United States of America.

This book should be required reading for high school and college students, but I don't think reading is held in such high esteem these days.  Better to be ignorant and unaware, than face the truth amidst the trembling of our soul.  Ms. Rand foresaw a nation consisting of three types: the producers (not looked upon with favor amongst the masses), the looters (the central planners and re-distributionists), and the leeches (those entitled to whatever the looters can take away from the producers).

At any rate, I found this book eye-opening and filled with the modern day philosophies that are currently reeking havoc on our free and prosperous society.  If you can handle over 1,000 pages of reading, the insight gained will be beneficial to those that refuse to give up our nation to the looters and leeches.  History has shown that this type of utopia can never be attained, only to leave destruction in its wake.

Friday, April 12, 2013

IS FREEDOM SUSTAINABLE?

Freedom Won




Freedom Ordered



Freedom Sustained????

“It will always be harder to be free than not to be free!”

 
America's deepest crisis is the crisis of sustainable freedom. Why? First of all, sustainable freedom is urgent for America because freedom is, and will always be, the issue of all issues for our nation. Augustine of Hippo (St. Augustine) argued that the best way to define a people is by their “loved thing held in common,” or what it is that they love supremely. Freedom is unquestionably what Americans loves supremely, and love of freedom is what makes us the people we are. This present crisis of sustainable freedom raises questions about the health of the American republic that we must take seriously.



From its very beginning, the United States was blessed with a sturdy birthright of freedom. This nation was born in freedom, it has expanded in freedom, it has resolved great conflicts in a “new birth of freedom,” it has taken its place as THE world power in defending freedom, and it now stands as the global colossus of freedom offering its gift to the world. Due largely to America, freedom is at the very heart and soul of the modern world, especially in its Western forms.



Sustainable freedom is urgent for America because freedom is far more difficult to sustain than most Americans realize. The glory of freedom should never blind anyone to its immoderate nature and its stern requirements that surround it. For at the heart of freedom lies a grand paradox: the greatest enemy of freedom is freedom.



Freedom faces a fundamental political challenge. Free societies must always maintain their freedom on two levels AT ONCE: at the level of their nation's constitution and at the level of their citizens' convictions. The fundamental laws and the fundamental “habits of the heart” are both essential to freedom. If the structures of liberty are well built, they will last as long as they are properly maintained. The spirit of liberty and the habits of the heart must be reinvigorated from generation to generation. Regardless of the strength of the constitutional structures, they can always be overrun in the end by the will of the people.

Machiavelli (Italian historian, politician, diplomat, philosopher, humanist,author, and considered the founding father of modern political science) rooted political restlessness in the fact that human appetities are by nature “insatiable” because human beings are “able to desire everything”, but unable “to secure everything.” As a result, their desire is always greater than the power of acquisition.



In a democratic republic, the rulers and the subjects are one and the same, so freedom constantly depends not only on the character of the nation's leaders, but also the character of its citizens. The self-restraint needed to sustain freedom is quite unnatural as it goes against the grain of humanness – especially in peaceful and prosperous periods. Freedom thrives on freedom and, mistaking power for freedom, expands naturally to produce the abuse of power that throttles freedom, unless that freedom is checked and balanced strongly, wisely, and constantly.



Freedom must be guarded vigilantly against internal as well as external dangers. However soft and however banal (lacking originality) it is, unbounded freedom simply cannot restrain itself by itself, and in the end its self-destructive tendency will show it's ugly head. Thus, like any free people, Americans should never be naïve and can never trust in freedom itself, for freedom alone can not bear the weight of freedom. Freedom has a chronic habit of undermining and destroying itself.

 
Sustainable freedom is urgent for America because many of the crises facing the United States have a direct bearing on freedom. Let's use the debt crisis as an active example. The blunt fact is that America's grand promotion of debt-leveraged consumerism has scorned the early-American stress on hard work, savings, thrift, and delayed gratification, which has turned Americans into a nation of perpetual debtors. Thus, with the United States shifting from producing to consuming, with American citizens consuming more than they save and with government spending more than it earns and promising to spend more, America's household debt, government debt and international debt keeps growing at alarming speed.



This current crisis mercilessly exposes the denuding (depriving of something important) of the American founders wisdom about the need for leadership with character, freedom with virtue, business with integrity and trust, and the rule of law with the cultivation of habits of the heart. In short, contrary to the founders, Americans today are heedlessly pursuing a vision of freedom that is short-lived and suicidal. Hubris is not simply arrogance but presumption born from the illusion of invulnerability. For this reason, nations at the height of their power and prosperity are especially deaf to warnings.



Sustainability is a recent and even voguish term, though history of human civilizations shows that the challenge of sustainability long precedes the word. Every political order known by man has shown the inability to develop an immunity to the forces of decline. The American irony is the our Founders addressed this issue as shrewdly as anyone in history, only for contemporary Americans to pay little attention to their founders or to the sustainable freedom that underlies any hope of maintaining our strength and prosperity. A sustainable society is a self-renewing society in which each generation chooses to do what the society needs them to do if the society is to last.



Arnold Toynbee (famous British historian) quotes, “History shows that all great nations commit suicide.” Abraham Lincoln personalizes this quote with his own understanding of our American challenge, “If destruction be our lot, we must ourselves be its author and finisher. As a nation of freemen, must live through all time, or die by suicide.” The free people of the American republic have no one to blame and nothing to fear but themselves. Our problem is not wolves at the door, but termites in the floor. Powerful free people die only by their own hand, and free people have no one to blame but themselves.

There are three tasks in establishing a free society that hopes to remain free – WINNING FREEDOM, ORDERING FREEDOM, and SUSTAINING FREEDOM. The first task of winning freedom is understandably considered the noblest and most glorious of the three and it easily overshadows the others. The second task is no less daring and significant than the first task. As has been shown in the last century and beyond, in pulling down oppressive strongholds, successful revolutions inevitably create a vacuum into which can flow a hundred forces detrimental and lethal to the ideals for which the revolution was fought. The French, Russian, and Chinese revolutions are classic examples of this truth.


Far from ordering freedom or any of the shiny visions for which they fought, they spiraled down to disorder and tyranny, far worse than any evil they replaced. “Revolutions may exorcise a haunted house, only to open the door to seven demons worse than the first.” Our founders, having won freedom, went on to provide a moral, cultural, and political framework in which freedom could flourish. People who would be free must be able to rule themselves, which is another way of saying that free people need saving from themselves as much as from an oppressive regime.

The third task of establishing a free republic is both the hardest and the least discussed today: SUSTAINING FREEDOM. As Benjamin Franklin came out of the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia and four months of secret deliberation, he was asked by a certain Mrs. Powell what kind of government they had bestowed upon the country, he replied, “A republic, Madam – if you can keep it.” The revolutionaries had won freedom. Then they had ordered the freedom they had won. But freedom was still not ensured. The challenge from then on was to sustain freedom – almost a dare, most certainly a duty, and one that is fraught with many dangers. As Thomas Paine wrote, “Those who expect to reap the blessings of freedom must, like men, undergo the fatigues of supporting it.”

The current American confidence smacks of the cocksure and the complacent rather than realism, and it relies on the capacity of public relations to conjure up reality through branding and image makeovers. So Americans trust in endlessly recycled slogans such a “renewing the American dream,” “restoring the American promise,” the best is yet to be,” and “America's future will always be greater than her past” - as if just saying so makes it all true. It is striking how the notion of sustainability has become common in such fields of economic growth and development, and in relationship with the environment but at the same time few Americans consider the sustainability of freedom.



Within the concept of sustained freedom, there exists a continual challenge, choices to be made, and consequences. There are always two ways in which things can go – advance or decline. Liberty is a marathon and not a sprint, and the task of freedom requires vigilance and perseverance if freedom is to be sustained.



We are rapidly reaching the point in Western consumer societies where people confuse freedom with choice, as they are dazzled daily by an ever-expanding array of external choices in consumer goods and lifestyle options. But the pursuit of freedom has led to an excess of choices and a scarcity of meaning and value – a point at which choice itself, rather than the content of any choice has become the heart of our supposed freedom. The result is that modern people value choice rather than good choice. When everything is permissable, no one is truly free, so it is ironic but not accidental that millions in “the land of the free” are in recovery groups from one addiction to another. Freedom requires truth and virtue, and the wisdom of their limits. Lord Acton (English Catholic historian, writer, and politician) claimed that freedom is “not the power of doing what we like but the right of being able to do what we ought.” When everything is tolerable, nothing will be true; and when nothing is true, no one will be free.



Our founders, being scholars of history, knew that it would be a great challenge to create a large republic on a continental scale. But they also recognized that the greatest challenge of all would be to create a lasting republic that would defy the centuries. However, this is the menace about which many modern Americans are least interested. It now takes a determined effort for modern Americans to see things as the founders saw them and feel about them as they felt, not only in terms of their individual lifes but also for the life of their nation and political arrangements.

When Cicero was fighting Rome's fateful shift from the early republic to the empire of the Caesars, he lamented the ravages of time on the great city of Rome. What was once fresh had faded. What had been revolutionary had become routine. The republican rhetoric was still there, but its once robust reality had gone. The form of it all was unaltered, but the substance had vanished without a trace.

The ancients' view of time was stern, but it needs to be heard by Americans today. “History devours its own children,” it was said. “Whatever it brings forth passes away someday.” Each form of government, whatever its defining principle, will finally be carried to excess. It will then breed a reaction to itself and end up as a ruin in the sand and a caution to generations. The great mistake of contemporary Americans is that they believe labor-saving technologies and instantaneous communication have brought them closer to conquering time as they have conquered space. According to such thinking, we are masters of our own lives, our world, and even of time itself.



Against such foolish thinking, the plain fact is that progress in science and technology does not mean progress in morality and humanity. Not surprising, the utopian blueprints and blithe (lacking due thought) progressivism have both flourished along with the wonders of modern scientific progress.



Our culture has entered into the “tyranny of now”. The postmodern mind, in contrast to the modern is obsessed with relativism and fragmentation. In this view, time is neither linear nor cyclical. It is pointillist – like truth and certainties of all kinds, it is pulverized into a thousand scattered points, each unrelated to the other and unrelated to the past and the future. There is no building on the past to construct the future. There is no building at all. There is only the endless succession of the fleeting now and its array of endless choices that open the future. There are only separate moments, episodes rather than stories, fragments rather than building blocks, shifting kaleidoscopes rather than meaningful narratives.



In such a world, dominated as ever by consumerism and driven by nihilistic (a doctrine that denies any objective ground of truth, especially of moral truths) but whose philosophy becomes “change for change's sake, the old is obsolete and the past is a ball and chain.” The new is by definition always new and improved, and the art of forgetting is more important than remembering and learning. Protean (displaying great diversity) flexibility has replaced wisdom born of precedent and experience.



The outcome of the confusion between America's modern and postmodern views of time is a tangle of contradictions. We are witnessing the emergence of a generation that both forgets the past and favors and fears the future. Americans today are building a society with a passion for all that is ephemeral (lasting a very short time), yet still absurdly presume that prosperity and freedom will remain permanent. In America's “instant society,” what is instantaneous is also immediate and therefore intense, and the result becomes the “tyranny of now.” But the real dangers are not what confronts us on the 24-7 news networks, as the real danger is opaque. Time erodes freedom in slow motion. Liberty is never lost all at once. The ultimate test of true freedom is not the economy or the military, but time.



Our framers held that, though the Constitution's barriers against the abuse of power are indispensable, they were only “parchment barriers.” Therefore, the letter of the law could never be more than part of the answer to sustained freedom. The American founders were not, in Joseph de Maistre's (French philosopher, writer, lawyer, and diplomat) words “poor men who imagine that nations can be constituted with ink.” Without strong ethics to support them, the best laws and the strongest institutions would only be ropes of sand. What the framers believed should complement and reinforce the Constitution and its separation of powers is the distinctive moral ecology that is at the heart of ordered liberty. Tocqueville* called it “the habits of the heart.” In short, sustainable freedom depends on the character of the rulers and the ruled alike, and on the vital trust between them.


  • Alexis de Tocqueville was a French political thinker and historian, best known for his Democracy in America. This work was published after his travels in the United States, and today is considered an early work of sociology and political science.  

In the cause of relativism, “virtue alone” is being replaced with “no virtue at all.” This is utter madness. Leadership without character, business without ethics, science without human values, and freedom without virtue will bring any republic to its knees. We humans act politically, inspired not only by faith, virtue, courage, honor, excellence, justice, prudence, generosity and compassion, but also by self-interest, self-preservation, power, greed, vanity, revenge, and convenience – and wise governance must take both sides into account. Checks and balances by themselves will never be enough. 
 

The laws of the land may provide external restraints on behavior, but the secret of freedom is what Englishman Lord Moulton called “obedience to the unenforcable,” which is a matter of virtue, which in turn is a matter of faith. Faith and virtue are therefore indispensible to freedom. Tocqueville emphatically agreed with this assessment, “My purpose (not turning Frenchmen into Americans) has rather been to demonstrate, using the American example, that their laws and, above all, their manners can permit a democratic people to remain free.”



According to Benjamin Franklin, “only a virtuous people are capable of freedom.” The need for virtue is simple and not open to question. Only virtue can supply the self-restraint that is the indispensible requirement for liberty. In George Washington's Farewell Address in 1796, he engages in this conversation. “Of all the dispositions and habits which lead to political prosperity, religion and morality are indispensible supports. In vain would that man claim the tribute of patriotism, who should labor to subvert these great pillars of human happiness, these firmest props of the duties of men and citizens.”



“If men are so wicked as we now see them with religion,” Benjamin Franklin said, “what would they be without it?”



Thomas Jefferson was a deist who undoubtedly loathed organized religion and serious theology of all kinds – Protestant, Catholic, and Jewish. Even the “doubters” such as Jefferson had a functional appreciation of religious faith. Ethan Allen told a story of a friend who met President Jefferson on his way to church on Sunday, “with his large red prayer book under his arm” and they exchanged greetings. “Which way are you walking, Mr. Jefferson?” the friend asked. “To church, Sir,” the president replied. “You are going to church, Mr. Jefferson? You don't believe a word in it.” “Sir,” said Mr. Jefferson, “no nation has ever yet existed or been governed without religion. Nor can be. The Christian religion is the best religion that has ever been given to man and I as Chief Magistrate of this nation am bound to give it the sanction of my example. Good morning, Sir.” In the case of Jefferson's public life, he was not so much hypocritical as he was a savvy realist. From where does our virtue come from?



Individual atheists and secularists can also be virtuous, and more so in some cases than those saying to be religious believers. But the political question is whether atheism and secularism can provide sufficient foundations to foster the needed virtues of a growing citizenry over the course of several generations. This task waits to be demonstrated. Voltaire, famed writer and philosopher, scornfully dismissed religion for “respectable people” like himself and his friends, though he advocated it for the rest: “I want my lawyer, my tailor, my servants, and even my wife to believe in God, because it means that I shall be cheated and robbed and cuckolded less often.”



 The United States is vulnerable to a crisis of cultural authority precisely because it is a nation by intention and by ideas, and it relies so deeply on them. If Toqueville was correct that in America religion is “the first of the political institutions,” then either the weakening or the repression of religion in America will be of first importance. “How can society fail to perish if, while the political bond is relaxed, the moral bond is not drawn tight?” As with any nation, the very principles by which America rose will determine the pathologies by which America will decline.

The English journalist G.K. Chesterton made a point after his tour of the United States in 1921. He was “no futurist,” he said, but there were certain things about America's future that anyone who thought carefully could see with little or no clairvoyance. American democracy had been grounded in convictions that were essentially religious, so those convictions could not decay or be rejected with impunity. American democracy would either keep it basis and remain democratic, or it would lose its basis and become “wildly and wickedly undemocratic.” Whichever way history went, he concluded, some “ultimate test will come.”

Will a free people remain free forever?



Freedom never lasts forever, because its very vitality is built on a combination of elements that are dynamic, difficult to hold together and easy to corrupt. History has shown that freedom loses its vigor and undermines itself.



An open ended feature of the American experiment lies in the gamble at the heart of democratic freedom. It can be expressed as such: Constitutionally speaking, there is no limit to what anyone in American can believe, though culturally speaking, there is an obvious limit. On the one hand, particular beliefs and opinions might arise that would undermine the foundations of the American experiment itself. On the other hand, the whole way of holding any beliefs could be undermined, either through tolerating all beliefs so indiscriminately that tolerance slumps into indifference or through obstructing all beliefs so strictly that they cannot exert any influence on public life.



For the founders, the way to resolve the tension between unlimited constitutional freedom and unquestioned cultural changes was through tough, robust, civil, open deliberation and debate. If the people's eventual decisions were deliberated and debated in this way, they would be wiser and more acceptable.



But therein lies the democratic gamble. The best, most true, most human, most just, most liberating and most beautiful views must prevail in open debate in generation after generation. If they do not, the American experiment will fail in the end, especially if there is no agreement as to whether there is any such thing as truth underlying the debates. In America today, truth itself, rather than particular claims to truth, is in question – and the political significance of that needs to be debated too.



Winston Churchill was once asked about his opinions on democracy. He replied, “the worst system there is, except for all others.” Freedom has been won and freedom has been ordered, but when it comes to sustaining freedom, the jury is still out.











Tuesday, April 2, 2013

PUBLIC EDUCATION IN AMERICA


We have known for many years that we need to improve our schools. The primary stumbling block is the vast disagreement about what should be improved, what factor(s) quantify the improvement, and what parties are primarily responsible for the needed improvement.



A definite case for needed improvement was made by A Nation At Risk , which warned in 1983 that our students were not keeping up with their international peers. Since that time, hundreds of reports and surveys have demonstrated that large numbers of young people leave school knowing very little about history, literature, foreign languages, the arts, geography, civics, or science. The consequences of inadequate education have been recently documented in books such as The Dumbest Generation, Just How Stupid Are We? and The Age of American Unreason. The authors of these books and many others describe in detail the alarming gaps in Americans' knowledge and understanding of political issues, scientific phenomena, historical events, literary allusions, and almost everything else one needs to know to make sense of the world. Without such knowledge and understanding, one tends to become a passive spectator rather than an active participant in the great decisions of our time.



Education is the key to developing human capital. The nature of our education system (mediocre or excellent) will influence our society far into the future. It will affect our economy and our civic and cultural life. Freedom can not be sustained if the citizens are uninformed and indifferent about the history of our nation and past nations, the different forms of government, and the workings of the economy. Our nation will not be able to prosper if it neglects to educate its children in the principles of science, technology, geography, literature, and the arts.



Our great challenge is to create a renaissance in education, one that goes well beyond the basic skills that have become the singular focus of federal activity. We need a renaissance that seeks to teach the best that has been known and done in every field of endeavor.



The current policies this nation is following have shown and continue to show that improvement in the schools is not happening. Much of what policymakers now demand is actually making our schools less effective and continues to degrade the intellectual capacity of our citizenry. The schools will surely be failures if students graduate knowing how to choose the right option from four bubbles on a multiple choice test, but at the same time are left unprepared to lead fulfilling lives, to be responsible citizens, and to make good choices for themselves, their families, and our society.



For the past century or more, education reformers have tried out their ideas in the schools. A wide variety of reformers and reform movements have offered their own diagnoses and cures. With the best of intentions, reformers have sought to correct deficiencies by introducing new pedagogical techniques, new ways of organizing classrooms, new technologies, new tests, new incentives, and new ways to govern schools. In every instance, reformers believed that their solution was the very one that would transform the schools, make learning fun, raise test scores, and usher in an age of educational efficiency. As one innovation follows another, as one reform overtakes the last, teachers may be forgiven if from time to time they suffer from an acute case of reform fatigue.



This constant reform churn is not the approach found in countries having successful schools. After years of studying successful schools from abroad, a common list of essential ingredients were found:


a strong curriculum; experienced teachers, effective instruction; willing students; adequate resources; and a community that values education.



The fundamentals of good education are to be found in the classroom, the home, the community, and the culture. The reformers in our time continue to look for shortcuts and quick answers. Untethered to any genuine philosophy of education, our current reforms have disappointed us and will continue to do so. The reform movement has been nothing but a series of distractions, wrong turns, and lost opportunities. It is time to reconsider not only the specific reforms, but also our very definition of reform.



Our educational problems are a function of our lack of educational vision, not a management problem that requires an army of business consultants. Certainly we should mobilize managerial talent that ensures school facilities are well maintained, that teachers have adequate supplies, that non-instructional services function correctly, and that schools are using resources wisely.



A few of our nation's reformers do suggest sound methods for improving schools, such as improving curriculum and instruction and improving the conditions in which students learn and teachers work, rather than endlessly squabbling over how school systems should be organized, managed, and controlled. I maintain that sound changes within curriculum and instruction are meaningless unless the community and the students truly value education, discipline, and rigorous study. In my 30+ years of experience, I have come to the conclusion that schools are only as successful as the community and culture in which it serves. The organization of the schools is not at fault for the ignorance that we deplore, but the lack of sound educational and behavioral values is a definite factor in the propagation of under performing schools.



Our schools will not improve if elected officials intrude into pedagogical (how do we teach) territory and make decisions that properly should be made by professional educators. Congress and state legislatures should not tell teachers how to teach, any more than they should tell surgeons how to perform operations (although, this could be right around the corner). Nor should the curriculum of the schools be the subject of a political negotiation among people that are neither knowledgeable about teaching or even well educated. Pedagogy should be the professional domain of the individual teachers. Curriculum (what to teach) should be determined by professional educators and scholars, after due public deliberation, acting within the authority invested in them by the schools, the districts, or states.



Our schools will not improve if we value only what tests measure. The tests we have now provide useful information about students' progress in reading and mathematics, but they cannot measure what matters most in education. Not everything that matters can be quantified. What is tested may ultimately be less important than what is untested, such as a student's ability to seek alternative explanations, to raise questions, to pursue knowledge on their own, and to think differently. If we do not treasure our individualists, we will lose the spirit of innovation, inquiry, imagination, and dissent that has contributed powerfully to the success of our society in many different fields of endeavor.



Our schools will not improve if we rely exclusively on tests as the means of deciding the fate of students, teachers, principals, and schools. When standardized tests are the primary means of evaluation and accountability, everyone feels pressure to raise the scores, by hook or crook. Some schools, as documented in several national cases, will cheat to get a reward or to avoid humiliation. Schools may manipulate who takes the test and who does not; district and state officials may fiddle with the scoring of the test. Districts and states may (and usually do) require intensive test preparation that mirrors the actual state tests and borders on institutionalized cheating. Any test score gains that result solely from incentives are meaningless because gains that are purchased with cash are short lived and have nothing to do with real education.


An unintended consequence that evolves from the dependence on standardized test scores for evaluating schools is that the lowest common denominator becomes our focus for achieving success. The schools have come to accept that the higher achievers will pass the minimum standards with very little effort, therefore the total focus of all endeavors is turned towards the underachievers. In essence, the curriculum of the school becomes driven by the lowest achievers, leaving the students with higher levels of competence and behavior to fend for themselves. The dumbed down state tests create a dumbed down environment, focused entirely on the lowest quartile of students.



Our schools will not improve if we expect them to act like private, profit-seeking enterprises. Schools are not a business, but a public good. The goal of education should not be producing higher test scores in one or two disciplines, but to educate children to become responsible people with well-developed minds and good character. The unrelenting focus on data that has become commonplace in recent years is distorting the nature and quality of education. There are many examples of healthy competition in schools, such as science fairs, essay contests, debates, chess tournaments, and athletic events. But the competition among schools to get higher scores is of a different nature; in the current climate it is sure to cause teachers to spend more time preparing students for state tests, not on thoughtful writing, critical reading, scientific experiments, or historical study.



The leader of each individual school is the principal. Shouldn't the leader be a proven master teacher and not some neophyte educator who may have taken a few leadership training courses but have little or no successful experience as teachers. The best principals should have a long apprenticeship as educators, first as teachers, then as assistant principals, and finally as principals. If principals have not spent much time as successful teachers, they are not qualified to judge others' teaching, nor can they assist new teachers.



Our schools cannot be improved by blind worship of data. Data are only as good as the measures used to create the numbers and as good as the underlying activities. If the measures are shoddy, then the data will be shoddy. If the data primarily reflects the amount of time invested in test-preparation activities, then the data are worthless. If the data are based on dumbed-down state tests, then the data are meaningless. A meaningful accountability system (for teachers, schools, and students), must include a variety of measures, not only dubious test scores. Our schools should be data-informed versus being data driven.



I disagree vehemently with most contemporary public school officials on the topic of school choice. The concern of the public schools is that with CHOICE and VOUCHERS, the motivated students and families will be siphoned away from the regular public schools. They fear that a continuation of this path will debilitate public education in many of our nation's school districts. Earlier in my career, I was in agreement with many of my peers, but recent events have turned me 180 degrees from that position.



Years ago, most public schools took on the culture and academic expectations of the community it served. In many suburban and rural districts, this trend still exists. Families are increasingly finding that the public schools (primarily in urban areas) are more committed to the goals and agenda of the political ruling class. In essence, public schools have become a primary propaganda tool of the ruling class. Unless a school can provide a safe environment for our children to learn and play and prepare them with a “sane/responsible” and rigorous liberal arts education, families deserve to have their children in schools that meet their standards and don't counter their personal family values.  While sympathetic to the challenges of today's public school system, I look at my grandaughter and respond, "I'm not going to let your problem become our problem."  There are many great public schools in the Valley of the Sun.  People who live in those districts are blessed, but those "not-blessed" have to worry about their own kids and the education that they will receive.



I guess what I am saying is that until the public schools clean up their act (usually not the fault of the particular school), parents have the right to use their “tax expenditures” to place their kids in the schools of their choice (including private schools).  A local columnist with the Arizona Republic shares my thoughts on the improvement of public schools, while facing the challenge of educating our own kids:



“There’s a lot of heartbreak in Arizona public education, mostly involving low-income kids not learning enough to obtain a decent shot at upward mobility. But there’s heartbreak when achieving kids are thwarted as well. There’s not enough room in Gilbert’s rigorous Classical Academy for all the students who want in. We keep trying to improve education by doing big things. Perhaps we should focus on smaller things – such as making sure any student who wants a rigorous curriculum can get it.”



Our schools can not be improved if we use them as society's all-purpose punching bag, blaming them for the ills of the economy, the dysfunction of families, and the erosion of civility. If there is one thing all educators know, it is that there is no single answer for educational improvement. I believe the columnist, Robert Robb, hit the nail on the head in that we keep trying to improve education by doing big things and wasting big amounts of money and energy in doing so. I see a similarity of the national goal of public school improvement with our nation's endless “war on poverty.” Tons of money and energy wasted and not much to show for it.



In closing, what is it that we want our kids to learn and accomplish by the time they graduate from school. We want our kids to be able to think for themselves when they are out in the world on their own. We want them to have good character and to make sound decisions in their life, their work, and their health. We want them to face life's joys and travails with courage and humor. We hope they will be kind and compassionate in their dealings with others. We want them to have a sense of justice and fairness. We want our kids to understand our nation, our world, and the challenges we face. We want them to be active, responsible citizens, prepared to think issues through carefully, to listen to differing views, and to reach decisions rationally. We want them to learn science and mathematics so they understand the problems of modern life and are able to participate in finding solutions. We want them to enjoy the rich artistic and cultural heritage of our society and other societies.



As we continue to make the testing regime our master, we may see our true goals recede farther and farther into the abyss.

Sunday, March 24, 2013

MARRIAGE: What it is, Why it matters, and the Consequences of Redefining It




 This piece is an edited and shortened version of an article written by Ryan T. Anderson.

Ryan T. Anderson researches and writes about marriage and religious liberty as the William E. Simon Fellow in Religion and a Free Society at The Heritage Foundation. He also focuses on justice and moral principles in economic thought, health care and education, and has expertise in bioethics and natural law theory.


His articles have appeared in The Wall Street Journal, First Things, Weekly Standard, National Review, Ricochet.com, New Atlantis, Claremont Review of Books, Touchstone, Books and Culture, Christianity Today, The City and Human Life Review.

Anderson received his bachelor of arts degree from Princeton University, graduating Phi Beta Kappa and magna cum laude. He is a doctoral candidate in political philosophy at the University of Notre Dame, where he received his master’s degree. His research spans the natural law tradition in conversation with classical and contemporary liberalism. The tentative title of his dissertation: “Beyond Private Property and Social Welfare: Economic Justice and Economic Rights.”

At the heart of the current debates about same-sex marriage are three crucial questions:  What is marriage, why does marriage matter for public policy, and what would be the consequences of redefining marriage to exclude sexual complementarity?

Marriage exists to bring a man and a woman together as husband and wife to be father and mother to any children their union produces.  It is based on the anthropological truth that men and women are different and complementary, the biological fact that reproduction depends on a man and a woman, and the social reality that children need both a mother and a father.  Marriage predates government.  It is the fundamental building block of all human civilization.  Marriage has public purposes that transcend private purposes.  This is why 41 states, with good reason, affirm that marriage is between a man and a woman.

Government recognizes marriage because it is an institution that benefits society in a way that no other relationship does.  Marriage is society's least restrictive means of ensuring the well-being of children.  While representing everyone's liberty, government rightly recognizes, protects, and promotes marriage as the ideal institution for childbearing and childrearing.

Promoting marriage as between man and woman does not ban any type of relationship.  Adults are free to make choices about their relationships, and they do not need government sanction or license to do so.  All Americans have the freedom to live as they choose, but no one has a right to redefine marriage for everyone else.

In recent decades, marriage has been weakened by a revisionist view that is more about adults' desires than a children's needs.  This reduces marriage to a system to approve emotional bonds or distribute legal privileges.

Redefining marriage to include same-sex relationships is the culmination of this revisionism, and it would leave emotional intensity as the only thing that sets marriage apart from other bonds.  Redefining marriage would legislate a new principle that marriage is whatever emotional bond the government says it is.

Redefining marriage does not simply expand the existing understanding of marriage.  It rejects the anthropological truth that marriage is based on the complementarity of man and woman, the biological fact that reproduction depends on man and a woman, and the social reality that children need a mother and a father.  Concerns for the common good requires protecting and strengthening marriage culture by promoting truth about marriage.

WHAT IS MARRIAGE? 

Marriage exists to bring a man and a woman together as husband and wife to be father and mother to any children their union produces.    

When a baby is born, there is always a mother nearby:  That is a fact of reproductive biology.  The question is whether a father will be involved in the life of that child and, if so, for how long.  Marriage increases the odds that a man will be committed to both the children that he helps create and the woman with whom he does so.

Marriage connects people and goods that otherwise tend to fragment.  It helps to connect sex with love, men with women, sex with babies, and babies with moms and dads.  Social, cultural, and legal signals and pressures can support or detract from the role of marriage in this regard.

Marriage is a uniquely comprehensive union.  In short, marriage unites a man and a woman holistically - emotionally and bodily, in acts of conjugal love and in the children such love brings forth - for the whole of life.

In reality, there is no such thing as "parenting".  There is mothering and there is fathering, and children do best with both.  While men and women are each capable of providing their children with a good upbringing, there are, on average, differences in the ways that mothers and fathers interact with their children and the functional roles that they play.

According to Rutgers University sociologist David Popenoe:

"We should disavow the notion that "mommies can make good daddies," just as we should disavow the popular notion that "daddies make good mommies."  The two sexes are different to the core, and each is necessary - culturally and biologically - for the optimal development of a human being."  

Marriage is the fundamental building block of all human civilization.  The government does not create marriage.  Marriage is a natural institution that predates government.  Society as a whole, not merely any given set of spouses, benefits from marriage.  This is because marriage helps to channel procreative love into a stable institution that provides for the orderly bearing and rearing of the next generation.

This understanding of marriage as the union of man and woman is shared by the Jewish, Christian, and Muslim traditions; by ancient Greek and Roman thinkers untouched by these religions; and by various Enlightenment philosophers.  The union of husband and wife arose in many places, over several centuries, in which same-sex marriage was nowhere on the radar.  Indeed, it arose in cultures that had no concept of sexual orientation and in some that fully accepted homoeroticism.

As with other public policy issues, religious voices on marriage should be welcomed in the public square.  Yet one not need appeal to distinctively religious arguments to understand why marriage - as a natural institution - is the union of man and woman.

WHY MARRIAGE MATTERS FOR POLICY   

Virtually every political community has regulated male-female sexual relationships.  This is not due to the fact that government cares about romance.  Government recognizes male-female sexual relationships because these alone produce new human beings.  For highly dependent infants, there is no path to physical, moral, and cultural maturity (personal responsibility) without a long and delicate process of ongoing care and supervision to which mothers and fathers bring unique gifts.  Unless children mature, they never will become healthy, upright, productive members of society.  Marriage exists to make men and women responsible to each other and to any children that they might have.

Sociologist James Q. Wilson wrote:

"Marriage is a socially arranged solution for the problem of getting people to stay together and care for children that the mere desire for children, and the sex that makes children possible, does not solve."  

Marriage is society's least restrictive means of ensuring the well-being of children.  Government regulation of marriage protects children by incentivizing men and women to commit to each other and take responsibility for their children.

Social science confirms the importance of marriage for children.  According to the best available sociological evidence, children fare best on virtually every examined indicator when reared by their wedded biological parents.  Studies that control for other factors, including poverty and even genetics, suggest that children reared in intact homes do best on educational achievement, emotional health, familial and sexual development, and delinquency and incarceration.

Father's matter and marriage helps to connect fathers to mothers and children.  Social science claiming to show that there are "no differences" in outcomes for children raised in same-sex households does not change this reality.  In fact, the most recent and sophisticated studies suggest that prior research is inadequate to support the assertion that it makes "no difference" whether a child was raised by same-sex partners.  A survey of 59 of the most prominent studies often cited for this claim shows that they drew primarily from small convenience samples that are not appropriate for generalizations to the whole population.

Meanwhile, recent studies using rigorous methods and robust samples confirm that children do better when raised by a married mother and father.  These include the New Family Structures Study by Professor Mark Regenerus at the University of Texas - Austin and a report based on Census data recently released in the highly respected journal Demography.  

Marriage benefits everyone because separating childbearing and childrearing from marriage burdens innocent bystanders; not just the children but the whole community.  More often than not, the community must step in to provide for their well-being and upbringing.  Thus, by encouraging marriage norms of monogamy, sexual exclusivity, and permanence, the state is strengthening civil society and reducing its own role.

A recent summary by Professor W. Bradford Wilcox of Virginia's National Marriage Project highlights the benefits:

"The core message....is that the wealth of nations depends in no small part on the health of the family.....marriage plays an underappreciated and important role in fostering long term economic growth, the viability of the welfare, the size and quality of the workforce, and the health of large sectors of the modern economy."

Given its economic benefits, it is no surprise that the decline of marriage most hurts the least well-off.  A leading indicator of whether someone will know poverty or prosperity is whether, growing up, he/she knew the love and security of having a married mother and father.  A recent report points out, "Being raised in a married family reduced a childs probability of living in poverty by about 82%.

While respecting everyone's liberty, government rightly recognizes, protects, and promotes marriage as the ideal institution for childbearing and childrearing.  Adults are free to make choices about their relationships without redefining marriage and do not need government sanction or license to do so.

*Important

Government is not in the business of affirming our love.  Rather, it leaves consenting adults free to live and love as they choose.  Contrary to what some say, there is no ban on same-sex marriage.  Nothing about it is illegal.  In all 50 states, two people of the same sex may choose to live together, choose to join a religious community that blesses their relationship, and choose a workplace offering joint benefits.  There is nothing illegal about this. 

What is at issue is whether the government will recognize such relationships as marriage - and then force every citizen, house of worship, and business to do so as well.  At issue is whether policy will coerce and compel others to recognize and affirm same-sex relationships as marriages.  All Americans have the freedom to live as they choose, but they do not have the right to redefine marriage for everyone else.


 THE CONSEQUENCES OF REDEFINING MARRIAGE

Redefining marriage would further disconnect childbearing from marriage.  That would hurt children, especially the most vulnerable.  It would deny as a matter of policy the ideal that children need a mother and a father.  Traditional marriage laws reinforce the idea that a married mother and father is the most appropriate environment for rearing children, as the best available social science suggests.

Recognizing same-sex relationships as marriages would legally abolish that ideal.  It would deny the significance of both mothering and fathering to children; that boys and girls tend to benefit from fathers and mothers in different ways.  Indeed, the law, public schools, and media would teach that mothers and fathers are fully interchangeable and that thinking otherwise is bigoted.

Leading LGBT advocates admit that redefining marriage changes its meaning.  E.J. Graff celebrates the fact that redefining marriage would change the "institution's message" so that it would "ever after stand for sexual choice, for cutting the link between sex and diapers."  Enacting same-sex marriage, she argues, "does more than just fit; it announces that marriage has changed shape."  

Government should exist to create the conditions under which individuals and freely formed communities can thrive.  The most important free community - the one on which all others depend - is the marriage based family.  The conditions for its thriving include the accommodations and pressures that marriage law provides for couples to stay together.  Redefining marriage would further erode marital norms, thrusting government further into leading roles for which it is poorly suited; parent and discipliner to the orphaned; provider to the neglected; and arbiter of disputes over custody, paternity, and visitation.  As the family weakens, welfare programs and correctional bureaucracies would grow.

Redefining marriage to include same-sex relationships is not ultimately about expanding the pool of people who are eligible to marry.  Redefining marriage is about cementing a new idea of marriage into the law - an idea whose baleful effects conservatives have fought for years.  The idea that romantic-emotional union is all that makes a marriage cannot explain or support the stabilizing norms that make marriage fitting for for family life.  It can only undermine those norms.

Redefining marriage would abandon the norm of male-female sexual conplementarity as an essential characteristic of marriage.  Making that optional would also make other essential characteristics of marriage - such as monogamy, exclusivity, and permanency optional.

New York University Professor Judith Stacey has expressed hope that redefining marriage would give marriage "varied, creative, and adaptive contours," leading some to question the limitations of Western marriage and seek....small group marriages."  In their statement "Beyond Same-Sex Marriage," more than 300 LGBT and allied scholars and advocates call for legally recognizing sexual relationships involving more than two partners.

Andrew Sullivan, who has extolled the spirituality of anonymous sex, also thinks that the openness of same-sex unions could enhance the bonds of husbands and wives:

"Same-sex unions often incorporate the virtues of friendship more effectively than traditional marriages; and at times, among gay male relationships, the openness of the contract makes it more likely to survive than many heterosexual bonds...There is more likely to be greater understanding of the need for extra-marital outlets between two men than between a man and a woman...Something of the gay relationship's necessary honesty, its flexibility, and its equality could undoubtedly help strengthen and inform many heterosexual bonds."        

Openness and flexibility are Sullivan's euphemisms for sexual infidelity.

Some advocates of redefining marriage embrace the goal of weakening the institution of marriage.  Victoria Brownsworth writes:

"..that allowing same-sex couples to marry will weaken the institution of marriage...It most certainly will do so, and that will make marriage a far better concept than it previously has been."

Professsor Ellen Willis celebrates the fact that "conferring the legitimacy of marriage on homosexual relations will introduce an implicit revolt against the institution into its very heart."  

Michelangelo Signorile urges same-sex couples to:

"demand the right to marry not as a way of adhering to society's moral codes but rather to debunk a myth and radically alter an archaic institution...Same sex couples should fight for same-sex marriage and its benefits and then, once granted, redefine the institution of marriage completely, because the most subversive action lesbians and gay men can undertake is to transform the notion of family, entirely." 


It is no surprise that there is already evidence of this occurring.  A federal judge in Utah allowed a legal challenge to anti-bigamy laws.  A bill that would allow a child to have three legal parents passed both houses of the California state legislature in 2012 before it was vetoed by the governor, who claimed he wanted to take more time to consider all the implications of this change.  The impetus of the bill was a lesbian same-sex relationship in which one partner was impregnated by a man.  The child possessed a biological mother and father, but the law recognizes the biological mother and her same-sex spouse, a "presumed mother," as the child's parents.

Redefining marriage marginalizes those with traditional views and leads to the erosion of religious liberty.  The law and culture will seek to eradicate such views through economic, social, and legal pressure.  If marriage is redefined, believing what virtually every human society once believed about marriage - a union of a man and woman ordered to procreation and family life - would be seen increasingly as a malicious prejudice to be driven to the margins of culture.  The consequences for religious believers are becoming apparent.

Thomas Messner has documented multiple instances in which redefining marriage has already become a nightmare for religious liberty.  If marriage is redefined to include same-sex relationships, then those who continue to believe the truth about marriage - that is by nature a union of man and woman - would face three different types of threats to their liberty; the administrative state, nondiscrimination law, and private actors in a culture that is now hostile to traditional views.

After Massachusetts redefined marriage to include same-sex relationships, Catholic Charities of Boston was forced to discontinue its adoption services rather than place children with same-sex couples.  Massachusetts public schools began teaching grade school students about same-sex marriage, defending their decision because they are committed to teaching about the world they live in, and in Massachusetts same-sex marriage is legal.  A Massachusetts appellate court ruled that parents have no right to exempt their children from these classes. 

The New Mexico Human Rights Commission prosecuted a photographer for declining to photograph a same-sex commitment ceremony.  Doctors in California were successfully sued for declining to perform an artificial insemination on a woman in a same-sex relationship.  Owners of a bed and breakfast in Illinois who declined to rent their facility for a same-sex civil union ceremony and reception were sued for violating the state nondiscrimination law.  A Georgia counselor was fired after she referred someone in a same-sex relationship to another counselor.  The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty reports that over 350 separate state anti-discrimination provisions would likely be triggered by recognition of same-sex marriage.