![]() | |||
| Freedom Won |
![]() | |||
| Freedom Ordered |
![]() |
| Freedom Sustained???? |
“It will always be
harder to be free than not to be free!”
America's deepest crisis is
the crisis of sustainable freedom. Why? First of all, sustainable
freedom is urgent for America because freedom is, and will always be,
the issue of all issues for our nation. Augustine of Hippo (St.
Augustine) argued that the best way to define a people is by their
“loved thing held in common,” or what it is that they love
supremely. Freedom is unquestionably what Americans loves supremely,
and love of freedom is what makes us the people we are. This present
crisis of sustainable freedom raises questions about the health of
the American republic that we must take seriously.
From its very beginning, the
United States was blessed with a sturdy birthright of freedom. This
nation was born in freedom, it has expanded in freedom, it has
resolved great conflicts in a “new birth of freedom,” it
has taken its place as THE world power in defending freedom, and it
now stands as the global colossus of freedom offering its gift to the
world. Due largely to America, freedom is at the very heart and soul
of the modern world, especially in its Western forms.
Sustainable freedom is
urgent for America because freedom is far more difficult to sustain
than most Americans realize. The glory of freedom should never blind
anyone to its immoderate nature and its stern requirements that
surround it. For at the heart of freedom lies a grand paradox: the
greatest enemy of freedom is freedom.
Freedom
faces a fundamental political challenge. Free societies must always
maintain their freedom on two levels AT ONCE: at the level of their
nation's constitution and at the level of their citizens'
convictions. The fundamental laws and the fundamental “habits
of the heart” are both
essential to freedom. If the structures of liberty are well built,
they will last as long as they are properly maintained. The spirit
of liberty and the habits of the heart must be reinvigorated from
generation to generation. Regardless of the strength of the
constitutional structures, they can always be overrun in the end by
the will of the people.
Machiavelli
(Italian historian, politician, diplomat, philosopher,
humanist,author, and considered the founding father of modern
political science) rooted political restlessness in the fact that
human appetities are by nature “insatiable” because human beings
are “able to desire everything”, but unable “to
secure everything.” As a
result, their desire is always greater than the power of acquisition.
In a
democratic republic, the rulers and the subjects are one and the
same, so freedom constantly depends not only on the character of the
nation's leaders, but also the character of its citizens. The
self-restraint needed to sustain freedom is quite unnatural as it
goes against the grain of humanness – especially in peaceful and
prosperous periods. Freedom thrives on freedom and, mistaking power
for freedom, expands naturally to produce the abuse of power that
throttles freedom, unless that freedom is checked and balanced
strongly, wisely, and constantly.
Freedom
must be guarded vigilantly against internal as well as external
dangers. However soft and however banal (lacking originality) it is,
unbounded freedom simply cannot restrain itself by itself, and in the
end its self-destructive tendency will show it's ugly head. Thus,
like any free people, Americans should never be naïve and can
never trust in freedom itself, for freedom alone can not bear the
weight of freedom. Freedom has a chronic habit of undermining and
destroying itself.
Sustainable
freedom is urgent for America because many of the crises facing the
United States have a direct bearing on freedom. Let's use the debt
crisis as an active example. The blunt fact is that America's grand
promotion of debt-leveraged consumerism has scorned the
early-American stress on hard work, savings, thrift, and delayed
gratification, which has turned Americans into a nation of perpetual
debtors. Thus, with the United States shifting from producing to
consuming, with American citizens consuming more than they save and
with government spending more than it earns and promising to spend
more, America's household debt, government debt and international
debt keeps growing at alarming speed.
This
current crisis mercilessly exposes the denuding (depriving of
something important) of the American founders wisdom about the need
for leadership with character, freedom with virtue, business with
integrity and trust, and the rule of law with the cultivation of
habits of the heart. In short, contrary to the founders, Americans
today are heedlessly pursuing a vision of freedom that is short-lived
and suicidal. Hubris is not simply arrogance but presumption born
from the illusion of invulnerability. For this reason, nations at
the height of their power and prosperity are especially deaf to
warnings.
Sustainability
is a recent and even voguish term, though history of human
civilizations shows that the challenge of sustainability long
precedes the word. Every political order known by man has shown the
inability to develop an immunity to the forces of decline. The
American irony is the our Founders addressed this issue as shrewdly
as anyone in history, only for contemporary Americans to pay little
attention to their founders or to the sustainable freedom that
underlies any hope of maintaining our strength and prosperity. A
sustainable society is a self-renewing society in which each
generation chooses to do what the society needs them to do if the
society is to last.
Arnold
Toynbee (famous British historian) quotes, “History shows
that all great nations commit suicide.”
Abraham Lincoln personalizes this quote with his own understanding
of our American challenge, “If destruction be our lot, we
must ourselves be its author and finisher. As a nation of freemen,
must live through all time, or die by suicide.” The
free people of the American republic have no one to blame and nothing
to fear but themselves. Our problem is not wolves at the door, but
termites in the floor. Powerful free people die only by their own
hand, and free people have no one to blame but themselves.
There
are three tasks in establishing a free society that hopes to remain
free – WINNING
FREEDOM, ORDERING FREEDOM, and SUSTAINING FREEDOM.
The first task of winning freedom is understandably considered the
noblest and most glorious of the three and it easily overshadows the
others. The second task is no less daring and significant than the
first task. As has been shown in the last century and beyond, in
pulling down oppressive strongholds, successful revolutions
inevitably create a vacuum into which can flow a hundred forces
detrimental and lethal to the ideals for which the revolution was
fought. The French, Russian, and Chinese revolutions are classic
examples of this truth.
Far
from ordering freedom or any of the shiny visions for which they
fought, they spiraled down to disorder and tyranny, far worse than
any evil they replaced. “Revolutions
may exorcise a haunted house, only to open the door to seven demons
worse than the first.” Our
founders, having won freedom, went on to provide a moral, cultural,
and political framework in which freedom could flourish. People who
would be free must be able to rule themselves, which is another way
of saying that free people need saving from themselves as much as
from an oppressive regime.
The
third task of establishing a free republic is both the hardest and
the least discussed today: SUSTAINING
FREEDOM.
As Benjamin Franklin came out of the Constitutional Convention in
Philadelphia and four months of secret deliberation, he was asked
by a certain Mrs. Powell what kind of government they had bestowed
upon the country, he replied, “A
republic, Madam – if you can keep
it.”
The
revolutionaries had won freedom. Then they had ordered the freedom
they had won. But freedom was still not ensured. The challenge from
then on was to sustain freedom – almost a dare, most certainly a
duty, and one that is fraught with many dangers. As Thomas Paine
wrote, “Those
who expect to reap the blessings of freedom must, like men, undergo
the fatigues of supporting it.”
The current American confidence smacks of the cocksure and the
complacent rather than realism, and it relies on the capacity of
public relations to conjure up reality through branding and image
makeovers. So Americans trust in endlessly recycled slogans such a
“renewing the American dream,” “restoring the American
promise,” the best is yet to be,” and “America's future will
always be greater than her past” - as if just saying so makes it
all true. It is striking how the notion of sustainability has become
common in such fields of economic growth and development, and in
relationship with the environment but at the same time few Americans
consider the sustainability of freedom.
Within the concept of sustained freedom, there exists a continual
challenge, choices to be made, and consequences. There are always
two ways in which things can go – advance or decline. Liberty is a
marathon and not a sprint, and the task of freedom requires vigilance
and perseverance if freedom is to be sustained.
We are
rapidly reaching the point in Western consumer societies where people
confuse freedom with choice, as they are dazzled daily by an
ever-expanding array of external choices in consumer goods and
lifestyle options. But the pursuit of freedom has led to an excess
of choices and a scarcity of meaning and value – a point at which
choice itself, rather than the content of any choice has become the
heart of our supposed freedom. The result is that modern people
value choice rather than good choice. When everything is
permissable, no one is truly free, so it is ironic but not accidental
that millions in “the land of the free” are in recovery
groups from one addiction to another. Freedom requires truth and
virtue, and the wisdom of their limits. Lord Acton (English Catholic
historian, writer, and politician) claimed that freedom is “not
the power of doing what we like but the right of being able to do
what we ought.” When everything is tolerable, nothing will be
true; and when nothing is true, no one will be free.
Our
founders, being scholars of history, knew that it would be a great
challenge to create a large republic on a continental scale. But
they also recognized that the greatest challenge of all would be to
create a lasting republic that would defy the centuries. However,
this is the menace about which many modern Americans are least
interested. It now takes a determined effort for modern Americans to
see things as the founders saw them and feel about them as they felt,
not only in terms of their individual lifes but also for the life of
their nation and political arrangements.
When
Cicero was fighting Rome's fateful shift from the early republic to
the empire of the Caesars, he lamented the ravages of time on the
great city of Rome. What was once fresh had faded. What had been
revolutionary had become routine. The republican rhetoric was still
there, but its once robust reality had gone. The form of it all was
unaltered, but the substance had vanished without a trace.
The
ancients' view of time was stern, but it needs to be heard by
Americans today. “History devours its own children,”
it was said. “Whatever
it brings forth passes away someday.” Each
form of government, whatever its defining principle, will finally be
carried to excess. It will then breed a reaction to itself and end
up as a ruin in the sand and a caution to generations. The great
mistake of contemporary Americans is that they believe labor-saving
technologies and instantaneous communication have brought them closer
to conquering time as they have conquered space. According to such
thinking, we are masters of our own lives, our world, and even of
time itself.
Against
such foolish thinking, the plain fact is that progress in science and
technology does not mean progress in morality and humanity. Not
surprising, the utopian blueprints and blithe (lacking due thought)
progressivism have both flourished along with the wonders of modern
scientific progress.
Our
culture has entered into the “tyranny of now”.
The postmodern mind, in contrast to the modern is obsessed with
relativism and fragmentation. In this view, time is neither linear
nor cyclical. It is pointillist – like truth and certainties of
all kinds, it is pulverized into a thousand scattered points, each
unrelated to the other and unrelated to the past and the future.
There is no building on the past to construct the future. There is
no building at all. There is only the endless succession of the
fleeting now and its array of endless choices that open the future.
There are only separate moments, episodes rather than stories,
fragments rather than building blocks, shifting kaleidoscopes rather
than meaningful narratives.
In
such a world, dominated as ever by consumerism and driven by
nihilistic (a doctrine that denies any objective ground of truth,
especially of moral truths) but whose philosophy becomes “change
for change's sake, the old is obsolete and the past is a ball and
chain.” The new is by
definition always new and improved, and the art of forgetting is more
important than remembering and learning. Protean (displaying great
diversity) flexibility has replaced wisdom born of precedent and
experience.
The
outcome of the confusion between America's modern and postmodern
views of time is a tangle of contradictions. We are witnessing the
emergence of a generation that both forgets the past and favors and
fears the future. Americans today are building a society with a
passion for all that is ephemeral (lasting a very short time), yet
still absurdly presume that prosperity and freedom will remain
permanent. In America's “instant society,”
what is instantaneous is also immediate and therefore intense, and
the result becomes the “tyranny of now.” But
the real dangers are not what confronts us on the 24-7 news networks,
as the real danger is opaque. Time erodes freedom in slow motion.
Liberty is never lost all at once. The ultimate test of true freedom
is not the economy or the military, but time.
Our
framers held that, though the Constitution's barriers against the
abuse of power are indispensable, they were only “parchment
barriers.” Therefore, the
letter of the law could never be more than part of the answer to
sustained freedom. The American founders were not, in Joseph de
Maistre's (French philosopher, writer, lawyer, and diplomat) words
“poor men who imagine that nations can be constituted
with ink.” Without strong
ethics to support them, the best laws and the strongest institutions
would only be ropes of sand. What the framers believed should
complement and reinforce the Constitution and its separation of
powers is the distinctive moral ecology that is at the heart of
ordered liberty. Tocqueville* called it “the habits of
the heart.” In short,
sustainable freedom depends on the character of the rulers and the
ruled alike, and on the vital trust between them.
- Alexis de Tocqueville was a French political thinker and historian, best known for his Democracy in America. This work was published after his travels in the United States, and today is considered an early work of sociology and political science.
In the cause of relativism, “virtue alone” is being replaced with “no virtue at all.” This is utter madness. Leadership without character, business without ethics, science without human values, and freedom without virtue will bring any republic to its knees. We humans act politically, inspired not only by faith, virtue, courage, honor, excellence, justice, prudence, generosity and compassion, but also by self-interest, self-preservation, power, greed, vanity, revenge, and convenience – and wise governance must take both sides into account. Checks and balances by themselves will never be enough.
The
laws of the land may provide external restraints on behavior, but the
secret of freedom is what Englishman Lord Moulton called “obedience
to the unenforcable,”
which is a matter of virtue, which in turn is a matter of faith.
Faith and virtue are therefore indispensible to freedom. Tocqueville
emphatically agreed with this assessment, “My
purpose
(not turning Frenchmen into Americans) has
rather been to demonstrate, using the American example, that their
laws and, above all, their manners can permit a democratic people to
remain free.”
According
to Benjamin Franklin, “only
a virtuous people are capable of freedom.” The
need for virtue is simple and not open to question. Only virtue can
supply the self-restraint that is the indispensible requirement for
liberty. In George Washington's Farewell Address in 1796, he engages
in this conversation. “Of
all the dispositions and habits which lead to political prosperity,
religion and morality are indispensible supports. In vain would that
man claim the tribute of patriotism, who should labor to subvert
these great pillars of human happiness, these firmest props of the
duties of men and citizens.”
“If
men are so wicked as we now see them with religion,” Benjamin
Franklin said,
“what would they be without it?”
Thomas
Jefferson was a deist who undoubtedly loathed organized religion and
serious theology of all kinds – Protestant, Catholic, and Jewish.
Even the “doubters” such as Jefferson had a functional
appreciation of religious faith. Ethan Allen told a story of a
friend who met President Jefferson on his way to church on Sunday,
“with his large red prayer book under his arm” and they
exchanged greetings. “Which way are you walking, Mr.
Jefferson?” the friend asked. “To church, Sir,” the
president replied. “You are going to church, Mr. Jefferson? You
don't believe a word in it.” “Sir,” said Mr. Jefferson,
“no nation has ever yet existed or been governed without
religion. Nor can be. The Christian religion is the best religion
that has ever been given to man and I as Chief Magistrate of this
nation am bound to give it the sanction of my example. Good morning,
Sir.” In the case of Jefferson's public life, he was not so
much hypocritical as he was a savvy realist. From where does our
virtue come from?
Individual
atheists and secularists can also be virtuous, and more so in some
cases than those saying to be religious believers. But the political
question is whether atheism and secularism can provide sufficient
foundations to foster the needed virtues of a growing citizenry over
the course of several generations. This task waits to be
demonstrated. Voltaire, famed writer and philosopher, scornfully
dismissed religion for “respectable people”
like himself and his friends, though he advocated it for the rest: “I
want my lawyer, my tailor, my servants, and even my wife to believe
in God, because it means that I shall be cheated and robbed and
cuckolded less often.”
The
United States is vulnerable to a crisis of cultural authority
precisely because it is a nation by intention and by ideas, and it
relies so deeply on them. If Toqueville was correct that in America
religion is “the first of the political institutions,”
then either the weakening or the repression of religion in America
will be of first importance. “How can society fail to perish
if, while the political bond is relaxed, the moral bond is not drawn
tight?” As with any nation, the very principles by which
America rose will determine the pathologies by which America will
decline.
The
English journalist G.K. Chesterton made a point after his tour of the
United States in 1921. He was “no futurist,” he said, but
there were certain things about America's future that anyone who
thought carefully could see with little or no clairvoyance. American
democracy had been grounded in convictions that were essentially
religious, so those convictions could not decay or be rejected with
impunity. American democracy would either keep it basis and remain
democratic, or it would lose its basis and become “wildly and
wickedly undemocratic.” Whichever way history went, he
concluded, some “ultimate test will come.”
Will
a free people remain free forever?
Freedom never lasts forever, because its very vitality is built on a
combination of elements that are dynamic, difficult to hold together
and easy to corrupt. History has shown that freedom loses its vigor
and undermines itself.
An open ended feature of the American experiment lies in the gamble
at the heart of democratic freedom. It can be expressed as such:
Constitutionally speaking, there is no limit to what anyone in
American can believe, though culturally speaking, there is an obvious
limit. On the one hand, particular beliefs and opinions might arise
that would undermine the foundations of the American experiment
itself. On the other hand, the whole way of holding any beliefs
could be undermined, either through tolerating all beliefs so
indiscriminately that tolerance slumps into indifference or through
obstructing all beliefs so strictly that they cannot exert any
influence on public life.
For the founders, the way to resolve the tension between unlimited
constitutional freedom and unquestioned cultural changes was through
tough, robust, civil, open deliberation and debate. If the people's
eventual decisions were deliberated and debated in this way, they
would be wiser and more acceptable.
But therein lies the democratic gamble. The best, most true, most
human, most just, most liberating and most beautiful views must
prevail in open debate in generation after generation. If they do
not, the American experiment will fail in the end, especially if
there is no agreement as to whether there is any such thing as truth
underlying the debates. In America today, truth itself, rather than
particular claims to truth, is in question – and the political
significance of that needs to be debated too.
Winston Churchill was once asked about his opinions on democracy. He
replied, “the worst system there is, except for all others.”
Freedom has been won and freedom has been ordered, but when it comes
to sustaining freedom, the jury is still out.



No comments:
Post a Comment