Culture

CULTURE.......

Language
: the oldest human institution and the most sophisticated medium of expression.

Arts & Sciences : the most advanced and refined forms of human expression.

Thought : the ways in which people perceive, interpret, and understand the world around them.

Spirituality : the value system transmitted through generations for the inner well-being of human beings, expressed through language and actions.

Social activities : the shared pursuits within a cultural community, demonstrated in a variety of festivities and life-celebrating events.

Interaction : the social aspects of human contact, including the give-and-take of socialization, negotiation, protocols, and conventions.

Monday, June 25, 2012

Words of Wisdom from F.A. Hayek and others...



From F.A. Hayek:  The Road To Serfdom; 1944 (Condensed and edited) 

The goal of central planning is described as taking care of the general welfare of the citizenry.  There has never been any real agreement as to the ends that are to be attained.  The effect is that a large number of people commit themselves to a journey without agreeing as to a specific final destination (I think of our War Against Poverty).  Ultimately, by the time the journey is advanced, most people have found that they have headed where they do not want to go.

About this time, a cry for a benevolent, economic dictator follows as a dictatorship is the most effective instrument of coercion, which is essential if central planning is to be effective.  Democracy and free elections, in itself, does not keep the source of power from dictatorial qualities (In our system, the growing Imperial Presidency will certainly lead to a dictatorship).


The totalitarian leader must collect around him a group which is prepared to submit to that discipline in which they are to impose by force on the rest of the people.  The Socialist Parties of old Europe were inhibited by their democratic ideals; they did not have the ruthlessness required for the performance of the chosen task.  The mistake of those parties that preceded Hitler and Mussolini was that they refused to take over the responsibilities of the type of government in which they were endorsing.  They still hoped for a majority that would agree on any particular plan which would benefit the WHOLE of society. (It has been said that a mixture of free market and socialism is worse than any of the two) Those coming after (the tyrants), had already learned the lesson that in a planned society the question can no longer be "on what do the majority of the people agree" but "what is the largest single group in whose members will sufficiently agree with the ruling class."


There are three primary reasons why a large group with similar views is not likely to be formed by the best that society has to offer, but rather by the worst elements of that society.  Who do the "dictators in waiting" go after to bring them into an absolute power?


  • The higher the education and intelligence of the individual becomes, the more their tastes and views are differentiated.  If we wish to find a high degree of uniformity in outlook, we have to descend to the regions of lower moral and intellectual standards.  This does not mean that the majority of people have a low moral standard, it merely means that the largest group of people whose values are similar are the people with the low standards (think of whom the present day Imperial Presidency panders to).  Very intelligent and educated people may be seduced by the dictatorial ruling class, but they do not make up the largest segment of the group in which they are a part of (the present day left wing intelligentsia and the Hollywood crowd).  
  • Since this group is not large enough to give sufficient weight to the leader's endeavors, he will have to increase their numbers by converting more to the same sort of fundamental beliefs.  He will have to gain the support of a docile and gullible, who have no strong convictions of their own but are ready to accept a ready-made system of values and imperfectly formed ideas if it is only drummed into their ears loudly and frequently (the head in the sand citizenry that does not want to take the time to fully understand the issues of the day; looking for a path of less resistance and outward approval, by not ever willling to take an unpopular stand - I call them the spineless). It will be those whose vague and imperfectly formed ideas are easily swayed and whose passions and emotions are easily aroused who will swell the ranks of the totalitarian party (a people whose life is guided more by emotion than by ideas and discipline).
  • To weld together a closely coherent body of supporters, the leader must appeal to a common weakness.  It seems to be easier for people to agree on a negative program (such as the hatred of a particular group or the envy of the better off) than on a positive task.  The contrast between "we" and "they" is consequently employed by those who seek the allegiance of huge masses.  The enemy may be internal, (such as those with strong religious beliefs or the rich).  At any rate, this technique has proven successful in the past and gives the leader greater freedom of action than any positive program.
Advancement within all totalitarian groups depends largely on a willingness to do immoral things.  The principal that the end justifies the means is the supreme rule in collectivist ethics.  There is nothing which the consistent collectivist must not be prepared to do if it serves "the good of the whole," ... (good is determined by the totalitarian regime).

Once one admits that the individual is merely a means to serve the ends of the state, most of those horrifying features of totalitarianism will follow out of necessity.  In the totalitarian machine there will be special opportunities for the ruthless and the unscrupulous.  Places of influence have no room for humanitarian feelings.

The most effective way of making people accept the validity of the values in which they are to serve is to persuade them that they are really the same as those they already held, but which were not properly understood or recognized before.  The most efficient technique is to use "old words" but change their meaning (freedom, human rights, equality, distorting the meaning and context of Biblical scriptures, etc.)


Traditional western values are held in very low esteem amongst the collectivists (past must be destroyed).  These virtues include independence, self-reliance, individual initiative, local responsibility, reliance on voluntary activity, non-interference with one's neighbor, and a healthy suspicion of power and authority.  These are the values that the collectivists are progressively destroying.


Our republic was based on the Rule of Law.  This means that government in all its actions is bound by rules fixed and announced beforehand - rules that make it possible to foresee with fair certainty how the authority will use its coercive powers in given circumstances.  This allows the individual to plan his affairs on the basis of this knowledge.  Within the rules of this game, the individual is free to pursue his personal ends, certain that the powers of government will not be used deliberately to frustrate his efforts.


Socialist economic planning involves the opposite of the Rule of Law.  The planning authority can not tie itself down in advance to general rules which prevent arbitrariness.  "The more the state plans, the more difficult planning becomes for the individual."


The difference between the Rule of Law and the Rule of Man is the same as that between providing signposts and commanding people which road to take.  In a planned society the law must legalize the arbitrary action of the planning authority.  Anything that the authority does is legal, thus its actions are not subject to any Rule of Law.  By giving government unlimited powers the most arbitrary rule can be made legal.


Immanuel Kant: "Man is free if he needs obey no person but solely the laws."


It is no stretch of the imagination to say that if we had to rely on central planning for the growth of our industrial system, it would never have reached the degree of differentiation and flexibility it has attained.  Modern civilization has been possible because it did not have to be consciously created.


Proponents of central planning will appease us that this authoritarian direction will only apply to economic matters.  They suggest that by giving up freedom in the less important aspects of our lives, we shall obtain freedom in the pursuit of higher values.  On this basis, people who abhor the idea of a political dictatorship are very vocal for a dictator in the economic realm.


Money IS one of the greatest instruments of freedom ever invented by man (money is the root of all evil, but money itself is not evil).  Money opens an astounding range of choice to the poor man - a range greater than that which not many generations ago was open only to the wealthy.  The so-called economic freedom which the planners promise us means precisely that we are to be relieved of the necessity of solving our own economic problems and that the bitter choices which this often involves are to be made for us.


Our freedom of choice in a competitive society rests on the fact that, if one person refuses to satisfy our wishes, we can turn to another.  But if we face a monopolist we are at his mercy.  An authoritarian directing the entire economic system would be the most powerful monopolist imaginable.


The will of the authority would shape and guide our daily lives, even more, in our position in the work place.  For most of us the time we spend at work is a large part of our whole life.  Our job usually determines where we live and amongst whom we live.  Few people ever have an abundance of choice of occupation.  But what matters is that we have some choice, that we are not absolutely tied to a job which has been chosen for us, and that if one position becomes intolerable, or our heart is set on another, there is usually a possibility to achieve this goal.  Nothing makes conditions more unbearable than the knowledge that no effort of ours can change them.


History shows us that any central planning government must control the trades and occupations, or the terms of renumeration, or both.  In almost all prior instances of central planning, the establishment of such controls and restrictions was among the first measures taken.


The problem with ignorant, short-sighted and lethargic people is they want to be relieved from the consequences of making choices or held accountable for the consequences of wrong choices.  In essence, people are not necessarily asking for others to make the choices for them, they just resent that choices are necessary.  What they resent is known as the economic problem (In short, the economic problem is the choice one must make, arising out of limited means and unlimited wants..)


What about planning for economic security?  There are two kinds of security: the certainty of a given minimum of sustenance for all and the security of a given standard of life.  With the wealth that has been found in the USA, having a first kind of security would appear to be "do-able" without giving away any form of general freedom.  I believe this type of security has been achieved in that minimum levels of food, shelter, and clothing have readily been available to the populace.  There is no reason why the state can not help organize a comprehensive system of social insurance to provide for those who get knocked back by the common hazards of life.


It is planning for the second kind of security which has a negative effect on liberty.  This is a planning designed to protect individuals or groups against any decrease of their incomes.  It has become increasingly true that members of each trade in which conditions improve are allowed to reap some of the increase in the form of higher wages and benefits.  Also, those in trades where demand has fallen off have nowhere to go, with the result being larger unemployment.  When the state offers grants of security to one group (unions, federal workers, favored businesses, etc) the insecurity of the rest always increases.  If you guarantee to some a fixed part of a variable cake, the share left to the rest is bound to fluctuate proportionally more than the size of the whole.  In other words, as the favored portion is mandated more security, the rest become less secure and more anxious.


"Ironic that our public university's propaganda machine has convinced so many that someone making a profit by employing 100 people is exploitation, but one bureaucrat commanding 100 people is honorable"

No comments:

Post a Comment