Culture

CULTURE.......

Language
: the oldest human institution and the most sophisticated medium of expression.

Arts & Sciences : the most advanced and refined forms of human expression.

Thought : the ways in which people perceive, interpret, and understand the world around them.

Spirituality : the value system transmitted through generations for the inner well-being of human beings, expressed through language and actions.

Social activities : the shared pursuits within a cultural community, demonstrated in a variety of festivities and life-celebrating events.

Interaction : the social aspects of human contact, including the give-and-take of socialization, negotiation, protocols, and conventions.

Tuesday, January 22, 2013

A NATION OF SINGLES (Part 1)



A developing demographic trend over the entire western world is that our populations are getting older.  With careful examination one can find that the reasons include a falling birth rate, a falling fertility rate, a falling marriage rate and the explosion in singles (that is people that never get married).

Experts on this type of topic are reporting that the real eye-opener is the increase in singles is much more impactful on our future than is the birth rate and fertility rate.  As a surging percentage of US voters, singles are a game changer.  They see the world differently in terms of their own personal security and the future, as is confirmed by the way they vote.

To get a sense of how powerful the marriage effect is, not just for women but also for men, we can look at the exit polls by marital status.  Among non-married voters, Obama beat Romney 62% - 35%.  Among married voters Romney won the vote handily by a tune of 56% - 42%.

We all had a sense that singles as a group favored Obama, but by that much?  Singles are a new and rapidly rising part of the population that has not been well accounted for in a demographic sense.

Why is this discussion important?  As this trend of the growing single class continues, it will have extreme ramifications on how our entitlement programs and taxes will settle out.  As a nation, we want maximal healthcare and minimal taxes.  Healthcare benefits have to be paid for by someone, and that trade-off is going to be large in terms of taxes, capital formation, productivity, and employment.  It is hard to overstate the implications of how healthcare demographics will affect our economy now and decades to come.

BIRTH RATE FALLS

In 2011, the US birthrate fell to a record low while the marriage rate continued to tumble.  The number of single Americans is now at a record high.  The implications of these developments are troubling, not only for the economy but in other sectors as well.

Some people confuse birth rate (births/1000 women) with the fertility rate (ave. number of children born to a woman during her lifetime).  In 1957, during the peak of the baby boom the birth rate was at a peak of 123 births/1000 women.  Today it has fallen to an all-time low of 63 births/1000 women.  The fertility rate needed to maintain the current US population is 2.1 children born to women of child bearing age.  The current fertility rate is now only 1.9 children and falling.

Although the declining US birth rate has not created a stark imbalance as shown in graying countries such as Japan or Italy, it should serve as a wake-up call for policymakers.  Robert Suro, a professor of public policy at the University of Southern California who studies trends in birth rates has warned:

"We've been assuming that when the Baby-Boomer population gets most expensive [to support], that there are going to be [enough] immigrants and their children who are going to be paying into [programs for the elderly], but in the wake of what's happened in the last five years, we have to reexamine those assumptions."

The question is, why is the fertility rate falling faster in recent years, especially among immigrant women?  Experts often point to the recession and financial crisis which unfolded in late 2007.  The current failing fertility rate mirrors to some extent what has happened during other recessions.  But in past recessions, the birth rate increased again once the economy recovered.  So why is it not happening this time? (hmmm, maybe the economy has NOT recovered)

There are numerous possible answers.  Let's start with the plunge in birth rates among immigrants.  Almost half of all immigrants to the US are of Hispanic origin.  But in recent years, immigration from Mexico has essentially dried up.  For the first time since the Great Depression, the net migration from Mexico to the U.S. has been zero.

Latino immigrants who have been here longer tend to adopt US behaviors and attitudes, including smaller families.  The decline amongst Latino's is most likely related to enhanced access to birth control and easier access to abortion.

In the US, as in other advanced nations, people are running away from marriage, children, and the family life at an amazing rate.  For example, 30% of German women today say that they do not intend to have children.  In Japan in 1960, 20% of women between 25 and 29 had never married; today the number is more than 60%.  It is estimated that up to 25% of all East Asian women will remain single up to age 50, and up to a third will remain childless.

Are we on the verge of becoming Japan and Europe with an even more aged population?  Demographers, from east to west, say YES!

IMPLICATIONS FOR THE FUTURE

Between 1910 and 1970, the "ever-married rate" went as high as 98.3% and never dipped below 92.8%.  But beginning in 1970, the ever-married number began a gradual decline so that by 2000 it stood at only 88.6%.

Today the numbers are even more striking, according to the 2010 Census.  Almost 24% of men, and 19% of women, between the ages of 35 and 44, have never been married.  If we look at the people between 20 and 34 (prime child bearing years), the numbers are even more startling:  67% of men and 57% of women in this group have never been married.  When all is said and done, over half of the voting-age population in America, and 40% of the people who actually voted this time around, are single. 

Very few political analysts emphasized how important the singles were to President Obama's reelection.  A lot of emphasis was put on the gender gap, but when counted, Obama won women by 11% whereas Romney won married women by the same exact margin.
Far more significant than the gender gap is the marriage gap. 

So what does this "singles" group look like?  Geographically, they tend to live in cities.  As urban density increases, marriage and birth rates fall in nearly a straight line.  Politicos James Carville and Stanley Greenberg put together some interesting data on singles.  Of the 111 million single eligible voters, 53 million are women and 58 million are men.  Only 5.7 million of these women are Hispanic and 9.7 million are African American.  Nearly 3/4 of all single women are white. 

Singles broke decisively for Obama, which was no surprise.  Though his margins with them were lower than they were in 2008, he still won them handily:  Obama was +16% among single men and +36% with single women.  But the real news wasn't how singles broke - it was that their share of the total vote increased by a whopping 6%.

That 6% increase meant 7.6 million more voters than in 2008.  They provided Obama with a margin of 2.9 million votes, which was 2/3 of his margin of victory.  We've heard so much about the increased share of the Hispanic voter, but it only increased about 1% from 2008 to 2012.  I'm sure Romney handlers are kicking themselves in the butt for missing this particular dynamic.

HOW DID WE BECOME A NATION OF SINGLES  

How did we get to an America where half of the population isn't married and somewhere between 10% and 15% of the population don't get married for the first time until they are approaching retirement?  This from Jonathan Last who did the research for an article found in the Weekly Standard:

"It is a complicated story involving marriage, among other factors, the rise of almost-universal higher education, the delay of marriage, urbanization, the invention of no-fault divorce, the legitimization of cohabitation, the increasing cost of raising children, the creation of a government entitlement system for the elderly childless to replace what grown children used to do for their parents.

But all of these causes are particular.  Looming beneath them all are two deep shifts.  The first is the waning of religion in American life.  As Joel Kotkin notes in a recent report titled ' The Rise of Post-Familialism,' one of the commonalities between all of the major world religions is that they elevate family and kinship to a central place in human existence.  Secularism tends toward agnosticism about the family.  This distinction has real-world consequences.  Take any cohort of Americans - by race, income, education - and them sort them by religious belief.  The more devout they are, the higher their rates of marriage and the more children they have.

The second shift is the dismantling of the iron triangle of sex, marriage, and childbearing.  Beginning in roughly 1970, the mastery of contraception decoupled sex from babymaking.  And with that link broken, the connections between sex and marriage - and finally between marriage and childbearing - were also severed.

Where is this trend line headed?  In a word, higher.  There are no indicators to suggest when and where it will level off.  Divorce rates have stabilized, but rates of cohabitation have continued to rise, leading many demographers to suspect that living together may be crowding out matrimony as a mode of family formation.  And increasing levels of education continue to push the average age at first marriage higher."  

The question, then, is whether America will continue following its glidepath to the destination the rest of the First World is already nearing.  Most experts believe that it will.  As the Austrian demographer Wolfgang Lutz put it, once a society begins veering away from marriage and childbearing, it becomes a "self-reinforcing mechanism" in which the cult of the individual holds greater and greater allure.

Johnathan Last continues:

"What then?  Culturally speaking, it's anybody's guess.  The more singletons we have, the more densely urban our living partners are likely to be.  Sociologist Eric Klinenberg believes that the masses of city-dwelling singles will sort themselves into 'urban tribes,' based not on kinship, but rather on shared interests.  The hipsters, the foodles, the dog people, and so on.  Klinenberg teaches at NYU, so he should know.  As a result, cities will gradually transform from centers of economic and cultural foment into what urban theorist Terry Nichols Clark calls 'the city as entertainment machine.'

The urban tribes may be insipid, but they are reasonably benign.  Kotkin sees larger cultural problems down the road.  '[A] society that is increasingly single and childless is likely to be more concerned with serving current needs than addressing the future,' he writes.  We could tilt more into a NOW society, geared towards consuming or recreating today, as opposed to nurturing and sacrificing for tomorrow."  (written by Kotkin, not originated by MLF). 

I want to add to what Mr. Kotkin has expressed.  I don't think anyone is saying that all single and childless adults have no concern for those who follow.  Using myself as an example, yes I care for the little ones in my community and what we leave for them, but I would actually fight to the death to secure the future of my own children and grandchildren.  In my opinion, this one factor has led to the many sacrifices that those in our nation's past have endured, even to death.  Also, to the detriment of our society, there are men and women with children that have absolutely no concern for their children's immediate welfare, much less any concern for their future.  I have and always will place strong and healthy family structures as the most important institution in our society.  

So what does this mean for the economy?  The economic effects are unclear.  On the one hand, judging from the booming economic progress in highly single countries such as Singapore and Taiwan, singleton's can work longer hours and move more easily for jobs.  On that level a more single society could be good for the economy.  But only for a period of time, as fewer babies are born to replace them.

There is another downside to this scenario of failing marriage rates and more singles in the workforce.  Demographers have found that without responsibility for families to provide for, unmarried American males have historically tended to drop out of the labor force prior to their normal retirement age, thus exacerbating recessionary tendencies in the economy.  Today's statistics of the unemployed show that married men's unemployment rate is much lower than the national rate, whereas the unemployment rate for single men is much higher than the national rate.  This dynamic of married man vs single man has perplexed observers for the last couple of generations.  From my personal perspective, it appears that men finally grow up when they have a wife and family as positive motivation.

During the American Industrial boom, observers from Europe came over to study the differences between the new nation as compared to the older nations of Europe.  Most of them gave much credence to the institution of marriage and religion as being foundational to what drove American's to be what they had become on the world stage.  Even today, survey after survey has shown that married people are happier, wealthier, and healthier than their single counterparts.  All of the research suggests that having married parents dramatically improves the well-being of children, both in their youth and later as adults.

As demographer Robert George stated after the election:

"..limited government cannot be maintained where the marriage culture collapses and families fail to form or easily dissolve.  Where these things happen, the health, education, and welfare functions of the family will have to be undertaken by someone, or some institution, and that will sooner or later be the government." 

Marriage is what made the West, and America in particular, so successful.  George continues:

"The two greatest institutions ever devised for lifting people out of poverty and enabling them to live in dignity are the [free] market economy and the institution of marriage.  These institutions will, in the end, stand or fall together." 

(slightly edited on 1/24/13  11:03am ; 2:05pm)
 

3 comments:

  1. Interesting topic and commentary, and you’ve put a lot of thought into it. I think there are additional issues at play to the decreasing marriage & birth rates in developed nations, including the impact of industrialization and other economic changes that for the first time opened paths outside of motherhood for women and have allowed families to survive with fewer offspring and raise them without the support of family/extended family.

    I hope you don’t mind, but since you’ve put so much effort into your argument and don’t have any comments yet, I thought I would offer mine, which, as you might guess, are going to come from a different perspective. Maybe they will spur some debate amongst your readers, even though I dislike debate and politics. But it’s so WELCOME in today’s superficial Facebook/Twitter world to come across writing that inspires me to think, so I hope you take it in that complimentary spirit. These are just my musings…

    Firstly, as a childless person, I don’t necessary agree with the conclusion that the single and childless demographic has, or will have, less concern about the future than the next person. I think perhaps there are some age issues that have more of a bearing on a person’s lack of concern for the future. Because for those of us who are in our mature years and are childless not by choice but by circumstance, I can’t think of a single one who isn’t concerned about the future and is not personally devastated that they do not have their own “next generation to concern themselves about.” It doesn’t mean they are not doing things, in their own way, to nurture and sacrifice for that next generation. For the people I know who are childless by choice, it is often concern FOR the future and the sustainability of our planet that has brought them to that choice. Americans today make up only 4% of the world’s population, but consume 25% of the world’s fossil fuel resources. Is there an argument that the American couple bearing 5-6 children shows more selfishness and less concern about the future of our planet by putting even more of a burden on the planet’s resources?

    Secondly, as a liberal, I don’t agree at all with the argument that singles voting for Obama is somehow evidence of shortsighted selfishness among this demographic. Obama’s platform embraces renewable energies, which speaks to someone who is truly interested in long-term sustainability of the planet. His platform embraces progressive reforms to public education, healthcare, tax and immigration, which is music to the ears of the person who believes in raising and educating healthy individuals regardless of gender, race and sexual orientation. Like all political platforms, there are faults and nothing is perfect, but for me, a vote for Obama does not say ‘I’m selfish and I want my entitlements’ as we hear over and over again. To me, my vote for Obama says, I am more committed making sacrifices now for the greater good of this planet and future generations than I am to lining the pockets of those who already have abundant wealth. Plain and simple. I think many single, childless voters would agree with me.

    Finally, as a human being cursed with an over-analytical mind, I will never be convinced that our culture’s “migration towards tolerance” is a bad thing, because I don’t believe that LACK of tolerance solves anything. In my heart of hearts, I will never be able to condemn others for living differently from the way I live my life or who believe differently from me, worship a God different from mine. I just can’t get myself to do it, my God did not build me to be intolerant, for whatever reason. I would argue that, instead of calling upon intolerance in order to hold onto old paradigms that are crumbling, like marriage and family, we should look to find ways to adapt those paradigms to what is inevitably becoming an increasingly-diverse, globally-connected, consumption-heavy population on a planet whose fragility is more and more apparent. This would be my rallying cry for the future.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Susan for your comments, as I know they come from your heart and as always are well thought out.

    If this article came across as a focus on the "childless" then I have missed my point. Having read it again, I can see that I did veer off my main agenda in a couple of instances. My intent was to be directed toward the growing demographic of the single person vs those married. According to the data, these two groups do tend to see things from a different lens, thus very relevant in the world in which we now live.

    The recently uncovered stat that nearly half of the American voters are single, definitely is a game changer. In that sense, the single voter's agenda will most likely prevail, as it has in the other western nations. Without a doubt, that demographic is quite homogenous in their voting patterns. This group is such a game changer, that I've come to the conclusion that THEY WIN and will continue to win. This is one of those things that this competitive personality is going to have to live with, whether I like it or not.

    Over time, I have come to recognize a real concern of the single mother and the single/childless. In today's environment, many single mother's have no help from the father(s). Without "help" from public resources, they and the kids really have no chance. My real gripe is with the "single" man that disowns all responsibility for the children they have brought into this world. Not one who can hide my real feelings, one of our biggest problems today (IMO) is the man problem. Very few "real men" in our society today. Expecting other people and institutions to make up for their lack is something that I have a difficult time dealing with.

    I also look at men and women that grow old, and have never raised a family (and as you say, many times its not by choice). Who is going to care for them? The public sector will have to take that on in greater measures, as the only alternative would be euthanasia. The data shows that this is and will continue to be the huge budget buster. I feel bad in that it can be such a lonely life for so many elderly. Consequently, I am not judging them as having done anything wrong, but it does bring forth a challenge for society in dealing with the elderly that have no family support of any kind.

    I'm glad you brought up tolerance. Actually, I don't even like to use that word (so why did I?) because it can be twisted in so many different directions. Yes, I have a value system that is based on a foundation that I hold as absolute truth. Other's may not accept my foundational truths, and I know that many people in this nation and world have very little "tolerance" for my beliefs and look at me as a danger for their vision of society and way of life. Honestly, it doesn't bother me at all. I know where they are coming from. In this article I wish I had used the phrase "acceptance with no absolutes". As a person, I do tolerate those with different values and belief systems, although I may not accept those values as being consistent with my overall belief system.
    I know on this topic of absolutes and right vs wrong, I have to agree to disagree with many people. No sense to argue, as it will become a circular discussion. Different people base their entire being and reason for existence on different foundations. In the personal arena, the "tolerance" issue is not a huge problem for any side. But when taken to the public square, a problem does develop. I read a recent article which I thought as being perceptive, in that states don't need to secede as the peoples of this nation are seceding from each other. That's a huge topic for another day.


    Again, thanks for your response and I am really sorry if I came across as bringing some kind of condemnation on the childless. In fact, I'm going to do some editing for that reason alone.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mike, You know we all read things through our own lenses, and so me being childless, I focused more on the particular quotes on childlessness you included. But I really want to tell you that I'm so glad you are writing things like this. I can't tell you how much I enjoyed just THINKING about the topic, and formulating my own ideas about it. And really, isn't that the point of good writing, to inspire others to think about things? So I tip my hat to you, and I am really looking forward to digging into that next topic you mentioned (because I have been dwelling on it too!), the idea that people (I think in all developed countries with technology, especially ours) are seceding from each other. Juicy. And important!

    ReplyDelete